News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by delichon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:42AM (#50546902)
I just watched a YouTube video about how a game like Red Dead Redemption 2 can never be made again because of the astounding, uneconomical level of detail. But it seems another one is being released tomorrow. I think the claim is backwards, and that this kind of detail will become table stakes for RPGs as leveraging AI becomes ubiquitous. And then some.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by claykkari on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:00AM (#50547109)
Also, not that everyone cares, but GTA 6 might be the last game of this scale created mostly without AI.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by ethbr1 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:54PM (#50554610)
I mean, if one looks at the great anime OVAs of the 80s, there certainly hasn't been anything created subsequently that matches their artistry. And probably never will be, because it's uneconomical to pay that many human illustrators (and there simply aren't as many skilled ones available without the job market).

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RwV4RyGOJZM

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by esalman on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:08PM (#50555554)
One of my friends is convinced Fromsoft will do it at some point.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by bigyabai on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @02:56PM (#50551270)
You should really play it, if you haven't. Nothing prevents an RDR2-style game from being made again, but the circumstances of the games industry makes it unlikely. You get a feel for how much money was spent recording foley, designing city layouts, connecting the fictional world, populating it with voice actors, studying horses/carriages, and interweaving it with an incredible story. I'm a Rockstar Games detractor, but RDR2 is my favorite of their bunch; the feeling of being a cowboy and vigilante in a world that's moving on from the "wild west" feels like a metaphor for how games are pivoting away from impressive AAA-style releases and towards more modest indie releases. It's Rockstar in-dialogue with their audience, telling them directly that their business might be the last of it's type. And as we watched Blizzard/Activision, ID Software and Bungie get acquired and subsequently downsized, it feels like Rockstar was right. They're one of the last cowboys on a shrinking frontier.

When we get an RDR2 or a GTAVI, it's easy to forget how many other games suffer development hell. Cyberpunk 2077 rewrote it's story mid-development, and it shows. MGSV stood on the cusp of greatness, and was delivered in an unfinished state because Kojima wasn't trusted by Konami. It's a gargantuan task to deliver games like this, and while they're still possible, I think the better word for it is "implausible" since the economics of game development no longer reward detailed releases like this.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by delichon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:10PM (#50551481)
I have over 500 hours in the game. It's fair to say I love it. But I don't agree with the people who think it's a literary masterpiece. Story-wise it feels contrived to be a setting for the violent action that we players crave. The gang was caught in a quagmire of self defeating actions by a delusional leader because the game requires it.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by bigyabai on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:24PM (#50551651)
It's definitely not perfect, I'm not afraid to agree with you there. All of Rockstar's stories suffer from being overly dramatized and whittled down to appeal to the mass-market. It does tug on the right heartstrings though, and the lack of moral ambiguity feels appropriate both for the target audience and the time period it wanted to evoke.

Even in the AI age, I find it hard to name a single studio besides Rockstar that could pitch such a technically ambitious title and get it across the finish line. Part of it probably hinges on telling a simple and inoffensive story, but most of it is the attention to detail that AI struggles with.