Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine
by kingstnap on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:54AM
(#50546339)
The original Quad9 article was purposely vague about the actual thing they will do, just vagueposting about not serving the french. My guess is its since the article might end up being read by non technical lawyers they didn't want to mention anything.
But the CTO did make a comment on hackernews. And thankfully CTOs can treat people here not like buffoons and give us the actual thing that will happen.
> It is probable that we will use geoIP filters to block French users from our services after November 24. We could apply this same geoIP filter list now to selectively block French users from reaching the sites that we've been told to make unavailable. But this would corrupt our core premise, which is that the DNS is not the right place for this to happen, and if we comply within France to meet the requirement then we accept the worst eventual outcome for users and we still do not have legally perfect coverage.
But the CTO did make a comment on hackernews. And thankfully CTOs can treat people here not like buffoons and give us the actual thing that will happen.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50195959
> It is probable that we will use geoIP filters to block French users from our services after November 24. We could apply this same geoIP filter list now to selectively block French users from reaching the sites that we've been told to make unavailable. But this would corrupt our core premise, which is that the DNS is not the right place for this to happen, and if we comply within France to meet the requirement then we accept the worst eventual outcome for users and we still do not have legally perfect coverage.