Re:Claude Gets Hella Paranoid
by codingdave on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:17AM
(#50545395)
> Claude read it and responded that it was the kind of proof it was looking for
That feels insecure. If it allows access to the remote system in any way before asking for proof, there will surely ways to trick that check. Will it grant itself more access just because you know the content of any file? Or does it have to be a new file? Does it have to contain a specific message, or could you just prove you know that a non-standard file exists at all? Could you use the read-only access in one session to gather the data for proving yourself in another session?
It would be interesting to see exactly what the minimal acceptable "proof" actually is.
That feels insecure. If it allows access to the remote system in any way before asking for proof, there will surely ways to trick that check. Will it grant itself more access just because you know the content of any file? Or does it have to be a new file? Does it have to contain a specific message, or could you just prove you know that a non-standard file exists at all? Could you use the read-only access in one session to gather the data for proving yourself in another session?
It would be interesting to see exactly what the minimal acceptable "proof" actually is.