> The US is always the good guy. If we refuse immigrants, we're patriots. If we accept them we're lifting others up.
Both statements are true, and both statements are useless.
But to get back to the point, "people" aren't impossible to please. If 90% of people want A and 10% of people want B, I'd guess the majority of people would say that implementing A pleases the people.
> If we refuse immigrants, we're nativist/xenophobic. If we accept them we're imperialist.
It's entirely possible to refuse immigrants while being imperialist and xenophobic, and it's entirely possible to accept immigrants while being imperialist and xenophobic.
I'm also fairly sure it'd be possible to make the majority of proponents of either position happy at the same time, but I'd guess that's not good enough, right?
https://read.gov/aesop/136.html