You are the first person anywhere on the internet that I've seen who rated Phi at all.
I think the general impression was that it was one of the most benchmaxxed models around (presumably not deliberately - probably because of all synthetic data they used).
I certainly found that as soon as you went slightly out of the distribution it was trained on (text book type data) it was terrible.
I felt that the training data and behaviours for this at the time were very OpenAI like, due to responses similar in structure to ChatGPT (like how ChatGPT now usually has a section at the end "Why this matters")