News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by myrmidon on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:14AM (#50530378)
Boycotting companies for their founders views/politics is very likely to end in utter hypocrisy.

The reason is that to be consistent with this, you'd have to know the political/ideological alignment of companies you interact with. But board members and CEOs can just be misanthropic assholes in private.

I'd honestly rather have open public discourse on opinions/views held by powerful people. If you boycott people at the first sign of wrongthink, all you achieve is punishing the people that are open and honest about their bigotry (and I'd personally much prefer those over the other bigots).

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by AlecSchueler on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:57AM (#50530758)
> Boycotting companies for their founders views/politics is very likely to end in utter hypocrisy.

> The reason is that to be consistent with this....

I don't have to be perfect. It's not hypocritical to work within the confines of my knowledge. Asking for more—with the suggestion that one shouldn't bother at all if nothing less than perfection is reached—is asking for something more than human.

> But board members and CEOs can just be misanthropic assholes in private.

They can and they are. What can I do about that? I can't read their minds, and I would think those who are vocal about it will be happier to use their riches to sway public perceptions.

> I'd honestly rather have open public discourse on opinions/views held by powerful people. If you boycott people at the first sign of wrongthink

So would I but A) calling it "wrongthink" is needlessly charged when it comes to such dehumanising language and B) it's not "the first sign" when it's multiple posts on multiple topics with a consistency covering multiple years, is it?

> all you achieve is punishing the people that are open and honest about their bigotry

Sounds good to me

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by myrmidon on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:55AM (#50532210)
> I don't have to be perfect. It's not hypocritical to work within the confines of my knowledge.

I'm not asking for perfection, nor for you to be doing or stopping any specific boycott.

All I'm saying is that instant-boycott in cases like this makes it very difficult not to be a hypocrite; you tacitly acknowledge this yourself by admitting that there are lots of silent bigots that go unpunished.

An analogy: If you reward randomly selected people (that you know nothing about, no name, age appearance, etc.) for their upper body strength, then that is clearly sexist-- because the correlation with gender is very strong. There is no excuse that "it couldn't be sexism because I clearly couldn't have known the gender".

> I can't read their minds, and I would think those who are vocal about it will be happier to use their riches to sway public perceptions.

Maybe. But instant condemnation/boycott suffocates any public discussion, because it very clearly incentivizes people to just not talk about such topics publicly, and things that you can't honestly talk about in public you can't really change either.

> "wrongthink" / "first sign"

I don't know how big the volume of posts is where this was cherry-picked from, nor how much "fuel" he got from similar-minded peers (resulting in posts much edgier than his actual views). But even if you barely polish those statements, I'd estimate that at least 10% of Americans would broadly agree (possibly more).

My personal, unfiltered opinion on this:

Boycott in such cases is "feelgood" activism that achieves less than nothing:

It's most certainly not going to change his view, it is quite unlikely to change the view of anyone that agrees with him, and it is not helping any victim (slandered immigrant or woman) either. On the other hand, it suffocates honest public debate and it looks bad to anyone on the fence because it's basically a witch hunt, which is why I personally refrain from sanctioning people like this even if I strongly disagree with them.

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by AlecSchueler on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @10:18AM (#50532536)
> ...very difficult not to be a hypocrite; you tacitly acknowledge this yourself by admitting...

Did I tacitly acknowledge it? Sorry, I thought I was doing so explicitly: I have no qualms with hypocrisy born out of an ignorance which I have no power to correct. That would be like arguing against gravity, some things just are what they are.

> An analogy: If you reward randomly selected people ....

You'll have to run this analogy past me again because I'm struggling to relate any part of it to the topic at hand

> It's most certainly not going to change his view, it is quite unlikely to change the view of anyone that agrees with him, and it is not helping any victim

I don't care to change his view but I wouldn't like to support his ability to influence politics or anything else that he might gain through being a financially successful CEO.

It certainly helps victims to publicly show that I don't tolerate their dehumanisation.

> it suffocates honest public debate and it looks bad to anyone on the fence

In what way? These issues are debated and discussed confidently. People dedicate their lives to research on these topics, there's a whole field of gender studies, there are conferences and panels aplenty. Migration and trans rights are some of the most visible topics in the media and are being discussed in parliaments and other legislatures that represent populations around the world.

In what way is my choosing not to financially support someone who comes away from those discussions with the view that women are "retards" stifle those discussions?

Is it because other bigots and people who are "on the fence" about hate speech might feel shamed into hiding their views? Good! Bring back shame.

> it's basically a witch hunt

"Basically" meaning not really? Witch hunts are horrible because they targeted innocent people, because the victims weren't actually witches and there was no way to prove someone was/wasn't a witch. In comparison with this case where we know with certainty that this man is a bigot who is publicly espousing hatred against people who already struggle against very systemic blockers.

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by myrmidon on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @02:50PM (#50537151)
> I have no qualms with hypocrisy born out of an ignorance which I have no power to correct.

Alright, that's what I wanted to get at. My position is that this double standard/conditionality is worse than anything such a boycott is likely to achieve.

> witch hunt

It's a witch hunt in my eyes because it is extra-judicial (there is obviously no interest to legalize/formalize the process), relies on group dynamics, has very little interest in precisely establishing guilt and applies obviously hypocritical standards: I'm fairly positive that no one crying boycott in this entire thread would find it desirable to be on the receiving end and face career consequences/job loss or similar because people from the other side of the political spectrum deem some of their old comments immoral or sinful.

One last point I'd like to make is that everyone thinks their own values/standards to be self-evident and correct; but a good majority would have spoken and acted with similar conviction against people like Turing in the past (for "abominable sodomy") barely a century ago, and would look really stupid today. So I'd caution against overconfidence in the timelessness of your own judgement, and much rather leave this to the courts when in doubt.

Thanks for the discussion; I feel that I at least understand your position better than before despite not being entirely convinced by it.