I'd rather people research unconventional or unpopular hypothesis then have everyone focused on one idea, or only focused on symptom management.
Your characterisation of my comment as "gosh I don't know, let's all just do our own research" isnt a fair representation of what I said.
If you disagree in my claim that we don't know what causes are leading to higher autism rates, I'd be interested to see what you know of that I may have missed.
I didn't say we should all do our own research, though are you opposed to people researching what is known today? Do you also take issue with informed consent, whick often requires doing your own research and asking the right questions?
I take issue with the idea of "antivaxers" as a concept entirely, I'm not on either side. Expecting that people are either all for every vaccine offered or opposed to every vaccine is absurd, and anyone holding those views is just in a political debate that has no useful value.
This is a hot topic so I feel the need to caveat each post here. I'm in no way saying vaccines, or any particular vaccine, is a cause of autism. I'm specifically pointing out that said link has never been found in any studies worth their salt. Down this chain of reasoning I'm simply adding that there is selection bias with regards to what hypothesise have been given funding at all, and its difficult to read an unbiased result from a pool of biased studies.
I'm arguing that the broad body of research disproving the link both may be valid and is biased. Biased because they start with the intent to disprove the link, and subject to selection bias as funding is almost exclusively given to any studies trying to disprove the link rather than prove it.
If you're questioning scientific process, its also worth noting that almost all research into causes of autism are epistemological studies. Those can prove likely correlation not likely causation, they similarly can't disprove causation but may help disprove correlation. We'd need controlled studies to know more, and rightfully so no one is willing to approve such a thing for a condition like autism.
The author had a competing vaccine, and made money selling diagnostic kits for the syndrome that he'd made up.
The same person peddled his anti-vax message elsewhere, including a 60 Minutes interview in the US, which largely kicked that off in the US.
This is where quite a lot of it comes from: one fraudster doing it for fear and money.
My point was simply that more diverse avenues of research is useful if we want to find answers. In the meantime, people also shouldn't be making claims or policy that can't be backed up with solid research results.
There has been specific research showing that there isn't a link. See the network of wikipedia articles starting from the one I linked.
Again, for clarity as many here seem to be assuming I'm arguing against vaccines or for some autism link - I'm not. I'm reading the data today and don't see any good explanation for why autism rates have increased and support a wide range of research. I would propose, though, that research dollars haven't chased a similarly broad range of hypothesis so its difficult to read into the funded studies that focus on one main view.
It's been given research dollars precisely to debunk the claims of fraudsters and anti-vaxxers. There's enough research there to be convincing in the negative. Right now, the research supports a conclusion of "I don't know, but it's not vaccines". (There may be also other negative results in the literature that are less well known.)
> why autism rates have increased
My hypothesis: largely for the same reason that left-handedness has "increased", namely increased diagnosis and increased acceptance.
My point here, before I lost track, was that (1) I haven't seen any convincing data showing a link between childhood vaccines and autism and (2) I don't take research considering said link as an issue, I'd rather people consider alternative ideas and either prove or disprove them through the usual scientific process.
I'm not elevating debunked fraud, nor am I claiming to know what is driving autism rates. And I was agreeing with you that an increased focus in diagnoses seems reasonable to explain some or all of the increased rate of autism - we could simply be looking harder and broadening the diagnostic window.
Vaccines have strong evidence and a long history of relative safety (nothing is 100% safe, I'm not taking a slight at them being unsafe).
If parents are reading to much into hypothesis related to autism causes, or ignoring evidence for vaccines used today, that's on them and up to them to decide.
Is your argument that we should silence research into alternative ideas of what may be causing autism? Or are we on the same page in different words, i.e. people should follow what is best understood today and make their own decisions?
I think this for the same reason I think people shouldn't make their own decisions regarding fire and electrical codes or driving safety.
So to that end, thanks for plating along here.
My personal opinion is that people should look to experts but make their own decisions. The caveat there is when their decisions directly impact others in a meaningful way.
With vaccines that's a gray area in my opinion, a vast majority of the population is eligible to get vaccinated and if they work then it shouldn't matter what their neighbor does. With building codes, I live in a rural area and if I poorly wire my barns its largely just my problem, someone living in a more densely populated area is in a different situation.
Your perspective amounts to a public health hazard.
Are you sure healthcare providers want to make decisions for everyone? Or is choice removed from the healthcare providers too, in a big feedback loop of being given no choice but to make choices for others?
> driving safety
Ironic how driver safety pushes people away from drugs, but here you're using it to prop up the position where taking drugs is mandatory.
Driver safety doesn't push people away from drugs, it pushes them away from psychoactive recreational drug usage. I want people to take their seizure, migraine, and heart drugs when driving, actually! This is a very strange comparison to make, unless you have a broad skepticism of medications, in which case we're very much not going to see eye to eye.
Also, you gave me reasons that we shouldn't grant healthcare providers limitless authority over everyone's treatment, not reasons that people not making individual decisions about their vaccinations constitute a public health hazard. It's hard to take your claims seriously when it feels like you aren't taking them seriously.
If you're anti-vax and you have a megaphone to scream from, then you're not just dumb, you're dangerous. If you have actual power AND a megaphone, chances are you are going to be responsible for thousands of deaths.
So there are certainly levels of anti-vax but it's mostly down to what kind of platform you have more than the opinions themselves (when it's true anti-vax sentiments, not just the milder "I think vaccines are great but I don't want to be first testing this" that we saw during Covid). Basically: the people who think Polio and Measles shouldn't be vaccinated against.
Your claim of an anti-vax person endangering their kids and neighbors is a tough one though. Assuming vaccines are effective, and that's heavily supported by research, the neighbors are safe if they chose to vaccinate. Legally we allow parents to be medical decision makers for their underage children, for better or whose thats the way it is and I don't know what alternatives would be beyond making every child a ward of the state. With the big caveat as well that some people have medical conditions preventing them from being able to take vaccines themselves, that's a difficult challenge similar to parents deciding in ways that much of the public disagrees with.
We didn't get rid of measles or polio though. Measles is showing back up today meaning it was never eradicated, just removed from at least symptomatic infection in the population. That's a big deal for sure and a huge win we shouldn't reverse, but claims of eradication are little more than political stunts.