Re:BugMeNot Has Closed
by ZephyrP on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @02:12AM
(#50528410)
Understandably still confused, even if there's explicit declarations and memorable lines like "If the “exceeds authorized access” clause criminalizes every violation of a computer-use policy, then millions of otherwise law-abiding citizens are criminals" (Van Buren v. United States, 593 U.S. 374), these seem built from a logic of fait accompli, or less cynically, simply contingent on whatever popular portrayals of computer use prevailed among non-specialists at the time of the ruling.
Imagine if, in a case like
'Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad Co. v. American Cyanamid Co.', which considers liability for the consequences of a hazardous chemicals spill transported via rail, the courts spent the majority of their time adjudicating if, or how many, were killed by gunpowder bombs in the engine room of a narrow gauge train and if it constituted a priori negligence not to have 100,000 gold bars available for ransom, as information considerate through many amicus briefs on the 1960s series "Gunsmoke" make most evident.
I mean, it would kinda be insane to get involved in the specifics of the case, right? Heck, to even get involved in the chemistry feels sloppy, at the very least I've got the feeling that the law should rise above any kind of petty indifference of that disciplines feating comprehensive empirical accounts of the nature of reality might engender, only providing it's own evolving doctrine of how the subjects of law should understand what the law really means and how we can achieve judgement sufficient to operate without comprehensive knowledge of existing case law!
Imagine if, in a case like 'Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad Co. v. American Cyanamid Co.', which considers liability for the consequences of a hazardous chemicals spill transported via rail, the courts spent the majority of their time adjudicating if, or how many, were killed by gunpowder bombs in the engine room of a narrow gauge train and if it constituted a priori negligence not to have 100,000 gold bars available for ransom, as information considerate through many amicus briefs on the 1960s series "Gunsmoke" make most evident.
I mean, it would kinda be insane to get involved in the specifics of the case, right? Heck, to even get involved in the chemistry feels sloppy, at the very least I've got the feeling that the law should rise above any kind of petty indifference of that disciplines feating comprehensive empirical accounts of the nature of reality might engender, only providing it's own evolving doctrine of how the subjects of law should understand what the law really means and how we can achieve judgement sufficient to operate without comprehensive knowledge of existing case law!