[dead]
You see a lot of this in older science fiction. They were writing "science fiction", but we read it as "science fiction".
There's tons of things like ESP or pheromones or giant red suns which a contemporary reader, who's not very familiar with the history of ideas or science, will read as colorful fantasy, and yet the original author was giving a speculation, or believed it was simple fact (https://gwern.net/dune-genetics#scientifiction).
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by WillAdams on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @08:45AM
(#50531287)
An example which arguably should be better known, and which dovetails neatly with the archaeological angle is H. Beam Piper's novella "Omnilingual", available in a lightly updated version at:
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by protocolture on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @05:13AM
(#50529571)
Lovecraft did this quite a lot. The Essential Lovecraft does a lot of "This happened to lovecraft, then he wrote this story" and a lot of it is either stuff he read or things that happened to him.
Same with the golden age of interplanetary fiction with biospheres on other planets. This was open scientific speculation until the space age showed us that they are not habitable, at least not to any life we might recognize.
"Young, warm, wet Venus" was one common trope that was thought to be likely at one time.
The solar system was thought to have formed from the outside in. Mars is older, drier, colder, deader, with an attenuated atmosphere... Earth is in the sweet spot... Venus is younger, wetter, and too much atmosphere...
Makes sense that old lost civilizations would be on Mars, and dinosaurs and cavepeople on Venus.