Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display
by carefree-bob on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @12:57AM
(#50527944)
The problem is that no one believes their opinion is bad, they believe other people's opinions are bad, and their own opinions are good. Just like no one believes that they are bad people, but they are convinced that those who don't share their judgments are bad people.
So the question is who decides, and if your answer is "they fight it out", then that is just rule by force, and you can drop the veneer of morality. All the other answers boil down to some form of "let social elites decide" or "let my priestly niche decide".
It is, in practice, impossible to untangle these opinions from people projecting their own failures onto others or seeking to promote their own well being at the expense of their enemies.
In practice, of course, it is the elites that decide, and history is filled with failed societies that flourished for a time and then fell into the grips of bad ideas that local elites were not able to abandon, and so ended up collapsing.
Therefore I would say this remains an unsolved problem, who gets to decide what is the good and bad opinion.
So the question is who decides, and if your answer is "they fight it out", then that is just rule by force, and you can drop the veneer of morality. All the other answers boil down to some form of "let social elites decide" or "let my priestly niche decide".
It is, in practice, impossible to untangle these opinions from people projecting their own failures onto others or seeking to promote their own well being at the expense of their enemies.
In practice, of course, it is the elites that decide, and history is filled with failed societies that flourished for a time and then fell into the grips of bad ideas that local elites were not able to abandon, and so ended up collapsing.
Therefore I would say this remains an unsolved problem, who gets to decide what is the good and bad opinion.