News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Active Directory Era Is Finally Over by Root_Denied on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:12PM (#50522498)
>It's sad it has to be said but bugs, PRs and stars don't pay the bills for the people building and maintaining software.

That's not their argument, it's that Infisical was able to grow into the entity that it is now due to those things, and without them it may never have gotten to the point that it could justifiably try to charge for enterprise anything.

Also those people did marketing, QA, promotion, and development for the platform without compensation, your statement makes it sound like there's no monetary value in those things. So the developer/company has a right to make money off of their work but the contributors don't? Especially when the contributors were providing work and value with the expectation that they were building something the community would be able to use, and now they're not going to be getting that in the future.

This is just another company moving towards enshittification as far as I can tell.

Re:The Active Directory Era Is Finally Over by jarym on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:38AM (#50530592)
> Infisical was able to grow into the entity that it is now due to those things

So? People chose to pick a commercial offering and were happy to pump it because it was OSS. No one forced them to do it.

> your statement makes it sound like there's no monetary value in those things

That's what you drew from it. And factually, there is no monetary value in those things because people did not ask to be compensated for it (I presume).

Remember, OSS took off partly because people wanted to work on stuff in their spare time and share it and on the messaging of escaping vendor lock-in in a world where most software was still proprietary and vendors did lots of sleazy things.

The level of entitlement is quite shocking. Instead of complaining people have so many more options, why don't they:

1) Take their data and go elsewhere?

2) Fork the code and maintain it themselves, opentofu style?

3) Just have an AI agent maintain the version they're happy with and keep it patched with security fixes?

So many options. Instead freeloaders just complain. Perhaps they should be paying customers instead.

Re:The Active Directory Era Is Finally Over by Root_Denied on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @06:21PM (#50539634)
>And factually, there is no monetary value in those things because people did not ask to be compensated for it (I presume).

Monetary value of work can be evaluated independent of whether someone asks to be paid or not, so this isn't factual in the slightest.

>The level of entitlement is quite shocking.

From another perspective this is corporate entitlement, as opposed to individual entitlement at scale.

Corporations rely heavily on OSS projects that underpin a number of critical technologies (you already know the XKCD comic that highlights this I'm sure), and this kind of behavior undercuts the social contract around work done by volunteers and hobbyists who aren't getting paid for it.

>Instead of complaining people have so many more options

There's nothing wrong, immoral, illegal, or unreasonable about someone complaining when an OSS project enshittifies and does a rug pull with regards to locking functionality behind a paywall.

>Take their data and go elsewhere?

That doesn't recoup time spent on this project, nor is it a reason not to express your opinion about the direction an OSS project has gone with your contributions.

>Fork the code and maintain it themselves, opentofu style?

This is what I expect will happen eventually if enough people care. That still doesn't invalidate complaints about enshittification of an OSS project.

>Just have an AI agent maintain the version they're happy with and keep it patched with security fixes?

Somewhat unfeasible for larger projects, especially if you end up with 5+ projects that all require some level of constant maintenance. It defeats the purpose of the OSS model which is to have a large number of people provide a smaller amount of effort than the full project maintenance would require on their own.