News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by tzs on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:40PM (#5052187)
> As Lessig reported, the plea bargain would have meant pleading guilty to a felony

Felonies can be expunged. See Randall Schwartz's case, for example.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jlgreco on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:49PM (#5052214)
Oh yeah, I guess a felony is no big deal then. How foolish of Aaron.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by tzs on Sunday January 13, 2013 @08:21PM (#5052759)
I guess I wasn't clear.

They seemed to have a pretty strong case against him, which means ending up with a felony label was pretty much a foregone conclusion if it went to trial.

A felony on your record is indeed a big deal. However, when you have the connections he did, and the reputation he did, a felony is not necessarily a "destroy your future" type big deal. Plenty of tech companies would have still jumped at the chance to hire him, for instance.

He was going to almost certainly end up with the felony tag regardless of whether or not he took the plea. Taking the plea gets him out and lets him get right to building his life back, and working on getting his record expunged.

Going to jail for, say, 10 years, not only delays all that by 10 years, but also makes it much harder. 10 years is a long time in the world of internet fame. Connections and reputations fade.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by nitrogen on Sunday January 13, 2013 @10:15PM (#5053107)
I was under the impression that the offered plea bargain still included an excessive amount of prison time and pleading guilty on all counts.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by MichaelSalib on Sunday January 13, 2013 @06:56PM (#5052453)
With respect, was there any problem with the felony besides his ego? I mean, I know people whose lifelong dream is to be a defense attorney. For those folks, a felony would be a huge problem since it would keep them from gaining admission to the bar.

Did Swartz have a similar issue? Or was he unable to bear the thought of being called names by that paragon of moral legitimacy known as the US government?

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by rms on Sunday January 13, 2013 @07:01PM (#5052462)
Being a felon seriously decreases ones ability to move internationally.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jlgreco on Sunday January 13, 2013 @07:11PM (#5052508)
It also hurts employment (not just if you want to be a lawyer...) and even housing prospects. Being a felon very effectively makes you a second class citizen.

Even ignoring all of that, there is the factor of being forced to submit before an unjust power. The "felon" assignment did not represent just a label, but also total submission. Just summing this up as a problem with his "ego" may seem a good way to marginalize this consideration, but it is incredibly transparent.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by MichaelSalib on Sunday January 13, 2013 @07:28PM (#5052562)
Ah, thanks for explaining.

Is the "moving internationally" issue a question of travel or permanent residency?

I get how a felony conviction might be a big deal for someone with a GED and no money and no connections. But Swartz had lots of connections and lots of money and was widely respected in professional circles. I really can't see any startup that he wanted to work for rejecting him over his felony conviction. And while some owners might not want to rent to people with violent felony records, I'm having trouble seeing many owners reject an accomplished man with money and recommendation letters from Larry Lessig and Cory Doctrow.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by ramanujan on Sunday January 13, 2013 @07:39PM (#5052598)
He had no money left, was already bankrupt after defending himself to this point...Besides, this is the wrong question - on what earth should it even be possible for a prosecutor to threaten thirty five years and a felony conviction for this sort of thing? That kind of sentence is for attempted murder, it is a few years short of life in prison. This was wrong, this was not right. Prosecutions like these mean that we lose our humanity.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by rprasad on Monday January 14, 2013 @02:12AM (#5053634)
Congress wrote the law making those acts a crime and imposing sentencing guidelines, not the USDOJ.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:55PM (#5058058)
The DOJ lobbied for these laws and they routinely lobby to make sentencing more severe. They make the recommendations and congress implements.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by rms on Sunday January 13, 2013 @09:53PM (#5053055)
>Is the "moving internationally" issue a question of travel or permanent residency?

Both

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:52PM (#5058049)
Look, the bigger problem is spending 10 years in jail and coming back to a society that has called you a con artist in national newspapers after the DOJ gets to talk with the press. He went from being a respected and loved person who have a big career opportunity to being despised. I went through this and you know that it is almost impossible to find a girl to date after getting in this kind of trouble. They Google your name and say "Fraud" no way. He was facing 20 years in jail and feds do get sentences this long (probably would not have in this case) but Aaron was still a kid and doesn't understand that the government is not going to get 20 years on him. 20 years means no family, no children, probably no marriage, no work prospect, a life of shame. It's like having leprosy its awful.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:49PM (#5058032)
Not really. Only for a crime like murder.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by dinkumthinkum on Monday January 14, 2013 @01:32AM (#5053538)
You think being a felon is little more than being called a schoolyard name by the US government? Wow, this is a pretty childish understanding of the world. ... :(
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:46PM (#5058016)
No. Not federal felonies. Only state and under certain circumstances such as a person who is under 18.