News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 13, 2013 @04:01PM (#5051847)
From what I understand, he committed a felony and would most probably have been labelled a felon either way. I don't see this as a reason to tie up government resources in a trial whose outcome is basically a foregone conclusion. I do not endorse what he did being a felony. But that issue is only marginally relevant to the discussion of the prosecutor's behavior.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by andreyf on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:33PM (#5052164)
He was accused of committing a felony. There's quite a difference.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by emkemp on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:46PM (#5052206)
Then he should have gone to trial.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jlgreco on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:49PM (#5052219)
Even a not-guilty plea would have left him ruined.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by emkemp on Monday January 14, 2013 @12:34PM (#5055585)
How so? What was preventing him from setting up a legal defense fund and accepting contributions?

Hell, what if the judge had thrown out the charges?

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:33PM (#5057959)
Federal criminal charges don't get thrown out. That is very rare. The way the laws are written the feds were going to win. Aaron was trying to do something that should be legal, but the feds were going to get their win. The problem is that what they report to the press and what they actually win on at court can vary widely, so Aaron was going to be ruined and he was going to serve hard time in prison. He shouldn't have killed himself though. He could have had a prosperous life after prison, but his public reputation was destroyed forever.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 13, 2013 @06:17PM (#5052305)
There's not always so much of a difference between those two things. If he did the things he was accused of doing that is a felony. There's little doubt that he did those things (the downloading and such) so he, in all likelihood, did commit a felony. Let's not focus too much on technicalities and semantics.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by newman314 on Sunday January 13, 2013 @07:38PM (#5052593)
Please.

If you are accused of being a child molester, does it mean that we should all consider you guilty? But we should not quibble about such technicalities as you so blithely claim.

"Innocent until proven guilty". That's how the law works (and should)

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 13, 2013 @08:01PM (#5052681)
If I had openly admitted the facts and several reliable parties had corroborated them? Feel free to call me a child molester before my conviction in that case. Don't throw me in jail before proving it, of course, but you needn't qualify every single thing you say with "alleged."

If the facts aren't pretty well established, then of course it is wise to be more judicious.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by nkassis on Sunday January 13, 2013 @11:00PM (#5053220)
No one is denying that he did download those documents. What is mostly likely getting you downvoted is your assumption that his acts are felonies and that he would have been found guilty. That is debatable and why it would require a trial. That's why I would suggest not labeling someone a felon when no jury has had a chance to decide.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Monday January 14, 2013 @04:36PM (#5056805)
> your assumption that his acts are felonies and that he would have been found guilty

I understand that that is debatable. I don't view these things as foregone conclusions, only as highly likely outcomes. I'm not aware of any serious observers of the case who disagree, but if they exist it would be helpful to know about them.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by enraged_camel on Sunday January 13, 2013 @11:24PM (#5053281)
Thank the maker the justice system does not work the way you think it does.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by thenetwork on Monday January 14, 2013 @08:40PM (#5057988)
No I disagree with your statement entirely. He was trying to download scientific and court documents that were paid for with taxpayer money that are supposed to be FREE to the public. The controlled distribution of these free documents to private companies is a scam by the US government to generate revenues for friends of the government. Yes the government was going to win their case because Aaron had to break the law in order to try and make these documents available. However, what he could have done, was brought action against the government and continued to violate the law in order to bring attention to it. But he was too young and too scared by the weight of the prosecutorial charges. They weren't going to get 30 years agains the poor kid for trying to right a government wrong. They were going to get house arrest and probation. Aaron should have stuck in there but having been falsely acused of a federal crime once in my life I know that the desire to commit suicide is strong.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by rhizome on Sunday January 13, 2013 @04:57PM (#5052036)
most probably

Which means "maybe." The government should have to fight for these things, not have them handed a victory through sheer intimidation in the form of a plea bargain.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 13, 2013 @06:18PM (#5052311)
And the government was fully prepared to fight for them. So . . . the world is as it should be at least according to the parameters of your previous comment.

Also, "most probably" indicates a bias toward true, where maybe is more like 50-50. I did not say maybe, I said most probably. All degrees of likelihood are not the same for me, so please don't replace my words. If you did want to reword what I was saying, "not certainly" or "not definitely" would have been more appropriate.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by rhizome on Monday January 14, 2013 @02:24PM (#5056090)
I'm not rewording, I'm interpreting. "Maybe" covers the whole field of uncertainty, and unless you're going to show your work, vis a vis probability calculations (such as they may be), I'll just stick with that.

Regardless, you don't address my, "intimidation by plea bargain," angle, which speaks to their confidence. If they want to make an example of someone, which I hope we can agree was happening here, why even try to short circuit the process and evade establishing precedent? Even (or especially) for a careerist prosecutor's scoreboard, verdicts are more valuable than deals made.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by jamesaguilar on Monday January 14, 2013 @04:40PM (#5056826)
I addressed it in another comment on this thread. Intimidation by plea bargain could equally be referred to as "No reason to plea bargain if the punishment upon guilty verdict isn't worse."

> make an example of someone

I think you're reading more into the motives of the prosecutor than is actually available from the evidence.

> evade establishing precedent

I don't think they need a case to establish precedent here. The law isn't perfectly clear, so there are gray areas, but my reading of it (as a non-lawyer, and corroborated by lawyerly readings in other threads) is that aaron's case was pretty deep in the "illegal" territory.

Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by dinkumthinkum on Monday January 14, 2013 @01:28AM (#5053529)
Not to be mean about it but it doesn't seem like you know what the word "felon" means. If you are never convicted of a felony, you are not a felon. There are real legal implications beyond your sentence if you are convicted as a felon. I think you should look into the information, possibly on Wikipedia regarding this; it is very relevant and the fact that you think it's not is confusing to me.