Re:'Grey Rocking': The Life-Improving Power of Being Really,...
by graemep on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:16AM
(#50515977)
I disagree about the title Dr. Most people are quite used to its use as an academic title (which is older than its use as a medical one). Anyone who has gone to university will have have been taught by many people with doctorates. It is a common basis for jokes in things like sitcoms (which only work if the audience understand the difference). I know more people with PhDs socially than medical doctors.
Many of the most dubious theories in the area have been devised by psychiatrists who are medical doctors.
So you would never label anyone an abuser? What is someone beats their spouse if they do not do what they are told?
If so, why exclude someone who achieves the same objective through other means? Control of finances, control of children, lies, social isolation, constant yelling and put downs....?
> In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?).
Yes, there are blurry boundaries, but what I think you do not understand is just how extreme these people are. We all have bad traits, but for most people these are not the dominant elements in our personalities. We are talking about people who are self-centred, manipulative, deceitful, and controlling very extremely and consistently. People who will scream and yell every day, lie to others to make people look bad, use friends and family to put pressure on their spouse (including telling them they are bad), tell they are children they are wicked and stupid daily, and even publicly, do things (real specific example!) like unplug an internet connection to stop their spouse taking part in a zoom call with their family.
Dr Ramani actually addresses the issue of exact labels. She says in one video that a diagnosis does not matter. If you are faced with that sort of behaviour then you use the appropriate ways of dealing with it.
> Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services.
Do you expect children to be able to ask those services to intervene? I have already pointed out the practical problems with divorce. Divorce and moving out takes time and people have limited options. You grey rock in the meantime. It took me well over an year (and a lot of effort dealing with the courts) from telling my ex-wife I was divorcing her to her actually moving out. Techniques like grey rock help you understand that.
> I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
There are multiple problems with that. Firstly you need to identify the relationship as abusive. We are talking about people who are manipulative and deceitful. The labels help people realise that these people will never change, and how to deal with them. You also need to be able to go through things like the divorce process.
Society discourages people (especially men) from recognising that they are victims of abuse. There are huge pressures to keep a relationship going. People put up with a lot if they think its best for their children. You can face social pressure to keep a relationship going. A lot of people will just brush aside the issue.
I think another thing you underestimate is how years of manipulation and undermining affects people's self confidence and ability to function normally.
Many of the most dubious theories in the area have been devised by psychiatrists who are medical doctors.
So you would never label anyone an abuser? What is someone beats their spouse if they do not do what they are told?
If so, why exclude someone who achieves the same objective through other means? Control of finances, control of children, lies, social isolation, constant yelling and put downs....?
> In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?).
Yes, there are blurry boundaries, but what I think you do not understand is just how extreme these people are. We all have bad traits, but for most people these are not the dominant elements in our personalities. We are talking about people who are self-centred, manipulative, deceitful, and controlling very extremely and consistently. People who will scream and yell every day, lie to others to make people look bad, use friends and family to put pressure on their spouse (including telling them they are bad), tell they are children they are wicked and stupid daily, and even publicly, do things (real specific example!) like unplug an internet connection to stop their spouse taking part in a zoom call with their family.
Dr Ramani actually addresses the issue of exact labels. She says in one video that a diagnosis does not matter. If you are faced with that sort of behaviour then you use the appropriate ways of dealing with it.
> Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services.
Do you expect children to be able to ask those services to intervene? I have already pointed out the practical problems with divorce. Divorce and moving out takes time and people have limited options. You grey rock in the meantime. It took me well over an year (and a lot of effort dealing with the courts) from telling my ex-wife I was divorcing her to her actually moving out. Techniques like grey rock help you understand that.
> I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
There are multiple problems with that. Firstly you need to identify the relationship as abusive. We are talking about people who are manipulative and deceitful. The labels help people realise that these people will never change, and how to deal with them. You also need to be able to go through things like the divorce process.
Society discourages people (especially men) from recognising that they are victims of abuse. There are huge pressures to keep a relationship going. People put up with a lot if they think its best for their children. You can face social pressure to keep a relationship going. A lot of people will just brush aside the issue.
I think another thing you underestimate is how years of manipulation and undermining affects people's self confidence and ability to function normally.