News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:52AM (#50505205)
Not necessarily. This view contains an inherent contradiction. If the bugs require skill to find, then Project Zero makes sense because it donates that skill. But if the bugs require skill to find, then "someone else finds it" stops being certain. Alternatively, if the bugs don't require skill to find, then Project Zero is not actually doing anything valuable.

So it is absolutely possible that nobody would ever find a memory corruption bug in a Lucas Arts SCUMM VM video transcoder if Project Zero didn't go poking around.

But because they did, and chose NOT to fund the fix, they DO carry some fault for anyone who acts on the bug after they disclosed it. Or if it is fixed in time, they must accept responsibility for consuming resources of a project they use but did not contribute to.

And the free money printer argument is absurd. The projects that Google uses are notable enough that writing bugs on purpose would be self-defeating. A project that write bugs on purpose would simply lose all users and nobody would care anymore.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:14AM (#50506030)
What are you blabbing about? Do you want Google now to fund the laziness of every software/firmware vendor on the planet?
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:34AM (#50506141)
No, but how about they pay for project they use?
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:03AM (#50506302)
Are the projects they use requiring licenses for commercial use?
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:19AM (#50506402)
Did the projects ask for vulnerability scanning from Google?

Did they ask Google to decide how quickly they need to fix reported vulnerabilities?

Same free will Google uses to decide to spam them with reports, they could use to exempt those fixes from the 3 per month limit in Google’s already existing vulnerability fix reward program.

They don’t _have to_. But then I am free to call them out on it.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by Valectar on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:51AM (#50506947)
I think you're confused. Google isn't paying other people to fix bugs in their own software. Google pays people to find bugs in Google software so that they can fix it. The same service they are providing to other software projects, for free, they pay individuals for because finding bugs in Google software helps Google to improve it.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:40PM (#50509453)
Not at all. Those are 2 separate programs:

https://bughunters.google.com/about/rules/open-source/patch-...

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:23AM (#50507147)
> Did the projects ask for vulnerability scanning from Google?

Do projects ask hackers to hack them?

> Did they ask Google to decide how quickly they need to fix reported vulnerabilities?

It is irrelevant and this is the point you don't get: Google is not forcing anyone to do anything. They just say "I found this problem in your software, I am notifying you and in 30 days from now the whole world will know. Do what you wish with this information."

> They don’t _have to_. But then I am free to call them out on it.

It is the internet, do whatever makes you sleep better at night.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:45PM (#50509505)
That’s being disingenuous.

What is the purpose of the message that Google sends if not to pressure the project to fix the issue? And why is Google doing this at all if not to pressure specific behavior?

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:50PM (#50513796)
You should ask Google.

I think Googke is doing the world a big service publishing vulnerabilities as soon as they are found. It would be even better if they publish working exploits too.