News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jonathan James by testimoney2 on Saturday January 12, 2013 @11:21PM (#5049957)
Well I mean the guy commited crimes and entered private systems. Its not like he is innocent. Are you saying you want it to be legal to hack into any random system in the world ? (that would remove all the fun of hacking)

PS: And I have done some hacking, stolen some files, financial information a long time ago, but I agree that it is highly illegal and should be punished and I do regret my actions. Thankfully I stopped before it was too late

Re:Jonathan James by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:04AM (#5050039)
>highly illegal

This is the problem. It should be "illegal" but not "highly illegal" -- the penalties should be along the lines of trespass, e.g. 30 days in jail or a $1000 fine, not 30 years in prison and a million dollar fine.

More than that, the crimes need to be defined with actual specificity. Read the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act sometime if you want to scare yourself. It's preposterously vague. How about we repeal that in its entirety and defer to the laws that prohibit the actual bad stuff, like fraud, identity theft, misappropriation of trade secrets, etc.

If all you do is get root on a server and then leave, the penalty should be a $5 fine and a stern warning, and the same penalty for the "victim" who put an insecure server on the internet.

Re:Jonathan James by ghshephard on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:19AM (#5050060)
Not to go too far off track here - but should I get a penalty for not locking my door at home?
Re:Jonathan James by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:25AM (#5050070)
OK, forget the fine then, we'll just go with the stern warning.

The point is that they should both get the proverbial slap on the wrist -- the person who breaks in should be chastised but hasn't caused any real harm and the person who allowed it to happen should endeavor to be more careful and not redirect responsibility for something trivially harmful that they could have themselves prevented if they deemed it worthy of the required effort.

Re:Jonathan James by ghshephard on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:42AM (#5050094)
So, what your are saying, is that I shouldn't be penalized if I don't lock my door at home, but I have no basis to complain if someone comes into my house, snoops around, looks in drawers, and then leaves without damaging anything.

I'm actually ambivalent about this, but I'm always intrigued as to whether people's sense of "Protect yourself on the internet or you deserve what you get" translates to "Protect yourself at home, or you deserve to be burgled".

Indeed - one could take it so far as, "Protect yourself with a weapon late at night/in your home, or you deserve to be beaten/mugged/etc..." - but, in general, we recognize the black and white line somewhere between "ssh server" and "put in hospital with contusions" - I think the "snooping around my house with unlocked door" is the gray area.

Re:Jonathan James by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 13, 2013 @01:01AM (#5050120)
I think there is also an argument that the internet is different, both because pretty good security is reasonably within reach for the typical server operator (unlike the cost of e.g. vault-quality doors and walls in a home), and because your government can't protect you from the wider internet because most of it is outside of its jurisdiction.

In that situation having a bunch of mostly harmless curious kids banging around creating antibodies in the system is probably a net positive, so that you find out your security is broken when some kid (who isn't trying to avoid detection and steal your trade secrets) is the one who opens your eyes to the vulnerability instead of the eye opener being a Chinese company selling your secret formula for near-cost on the world market.

Re:Jonathan James by alan_cx on Sunday January 13, 2013 @08:32AM (#5050704)
Yes. If you get burgled and you insurance company discovers you didn't lock you home up, yeah, you will get a penalty.
Re:Jonathan James by caf on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:01AM (#5050032)
It certainly shouldn't attract a sentence considerably worse than violent crimes do.

There's a persuasive argument that no nonviolent crime should be punished by prison time at all.

Re:Jonathan James by w1ntermute on Saturday January 12, 2013 @11:34PM (#5049983)
Did you read the Wiki article? He claimed he wasn't responsible for the TJX hack, yet they were going to scapegoat him.
Re:Jonathan James by tkahn6 on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:07AM (#5050045)
Yes, he claimed that. It doesn't make it true.

His own father believed that he was involved.

Re:Jonathan James by cantankerous on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:24AM (#5050069)
It doesn't matter what's true. It matters what's provable. Otherwise he's innocent until shown to be guilty...regardless of what his father or anybody else thinks.
Re:Jonathan James by nitrogen on Sunday January 13, 2013 @04:11AM (#5050368)
I can't speak to this specific case, but I'm sure lots of fathers have been completely wrong about their sons.
Re:Jonathan James by monsterix on Saturday January 12, 2013 @11:38PM (#5049987)
How is it a crime to access (force access) content that belongs to the public? It was created using tax payers money and should have been available to the public without the hurdles in the first place.

Note the same content is now available over the Internet for free legally. So what has changed, and what was lost?