Re:The Claude Delusion
by voidhorse on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:11AM
(#50497642)
This article articulates several thoughts I share with the author well. If there is anything people in the technology industry lack, it's intellectual humility.
That, and, they are pitifully ahistorical people. Today's industry leaders are not sufficiently schooled in constructivism. No, I don't mean they all need to become radical constructivists, but they should all at least gain a passing familiarity with Foucault before they continue fucking with humanity's social mores and environments with impunity.
They won't, of course, because they are decidedly unreflective (see Andreessen), unphilosophical people. They are, oftentimes, the marquee examples of 'soulless' people fueled only by the incentive structures put before them by the economy. Money. Clout. "Progress". It's telling that, beyond the many examples of hubris like that of Gates, basically zero technologists have come out and examined the unspoken assumptions behind such terms as "progress", "alignment", "intelligence" and the difficult social problems fixing these terms would entail. Moreover, they interpret all of these terms using some reified capitalistic gloss and go on their merry way, because, in spite of their constant proclamations to the contrary, most of them are not, in fact, very intelligent beyond being savvy businessmen.
The employees bear the brunt of actual technical intelligence. Leadership bears little more than a passing ability to navigate an economic structure that, let's face it, is already very forgiving to them and essentially places little to no responsibility on them after certain levels of scale are achieved. But none of that scale is possible without the vast legions of employees. Oftentimes the 'genius idea' is about 0.5% of the actual success of an endeavor, yet we cling to an old "great men of history" form of thinking and allow the public to prop up these individuals as though they are demigods.
That, and, they are pitifully ahistorical people. Today's industry leaders are not sufficiently schooled in constructivism. No, I don't mean they all need to become radical constructivists, but they should all at least gain a passing familiarity with Foucault before they continue fucking with humanity's social mores and environments with impunity.
They won't, of course, because they are decidedly unreflective (see Andreessen), unphilosophical people. They are, oftentimes, the marquee examples of 'soulless' people fueled only by the incentive structures put before them by the economy. Money. Clout. "Progress". It's telling that, beyond the many examples of hubris like that of Gates, basically zero technologists have come out and examined the unspoken assumptions behind such terms as "progress", "alignment", "intelligence" and the difficult social problems fixing these terms would entail. Moreover, they interpret all of these terms using some reified capitalistic gloss and go on their merry way, because, in spite of their constant proclamations to the contrary, most of them are not, in fact, very intelligent beyond being savvy businessmen.
The employees bear the brunt of actual technical intelligence. Leadership bears little more than a passing ability to navigate an economic structure that, let's face it, is already very forgiving to them and essentially places little to no responsibility on them after certain levels of scale are achieved. But none of that scale is possible without the vast legions of employees. Oftentimes the 'genius idea' is about 0.5% of the actual success of an endeavor, yet we cling to an old "great men of history" form of thinking and allow the public to prop up these individuals as though they are demigods.