News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Claude Delusion by api on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:26AM (#50497259)
At the end this repeats that AI has reversed huge reductions in CO2 emissions. I keep seeing this. Is this chart wrong?

https://ourworldindata.org/profile/co2/united-states

The second chart is the one I’m looking at. Where is the 15 year reversal? If zoom in I see a small uptick. Not a 15 year trend reversal.

Re:The Claude Delusion by yellow_lead on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:29AM (#50497281)
Re:The Claude Delusion by robkeane on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:33AM (#50497312)
Yeah, it's still not true.
Re:The Claude Delusion by ch4s3 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:32AM (#50497311)
It’s just plainly not true. Yes AI uses electricity but it’s not that large a percentage of global electricity use. A lot has been happening globally that effects energy use the last few years.
Re:The Claude Delusion by api on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:46AM (#50497436)
I also tend to blame any uptick on electing a president that explicitly ran on burning more coal and spent money to subsidize keeping otherwise obsolete coal online.

I keep hearing this AI water and energy panic stuff. I’m a believer in facts, so I go looking for it, and it’s just not there. Water use is similar to golf courses and light agriculture, though I can see it being a problem in places like the Southwest. The electricity use is decent but not at the levels people are losing their minds over.

It’s just not there.

I can see some of the complaints over noise and political corruption like special tax breaks and deals.

Re:The Claude Delusion by ch4s3 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:08AM (#50497630)
US coal use peaked in 2007 and only had a small uptick in 2025 mostly down to demand for electricity outstripping the ability to build new supply. It had little to do with current administration policy. In other circumstances the coal plants that went back online may have been converted to natural gas but it’s hard to say what then counter factual would have been.
Re:The Claude Delusion by simoncion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:44AM (#50497413)
I note that that chart doesn't contain data for 2026. It also doesn't contain data for 2030.

Unless something catastrophic happens, [0] construction four years out is effectively locked in. When what's being constructed is expected to increase CO2 emissions by ~50% after it's built, it's quite reasonable to assert that the LLM Industry has reversed our collective work on cutting CO2 emissions. It's exceedingly reasonable to bitch bitterly about it when those very same entities driving the construction today were screaming left and right about all of the initiatives they'd been championing to reduce power consumption and Save The Planet and whatnot just a few years ago.

[0] ..such as a fuckoff-huge bubble that's being used to justify said construction messily exploding...

Re:The Claude Delusion by api on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:00AM (#50497552)
The construction plans are nuts and it looks very much like a real estate bubble.

Chip efficiency gains will mean that by 2030 you’ll be getting 100X the inference throughput on half the power. All this construction is not necessary.

Re:The Claude Delusion by simoncion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:46AM (#50497937)
> The construction plans are nuts...

They're in line with what's needed to meet the revenue projections of the LLM companies. Your "100x the inference" assertion ignores the most expensive part of the work of creating SOTA LLMs... the "training". That is what the DCs are primarily being built to do.

Re:The Claude Delusion by dolmen on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:38PM (#50504067)
If this is about training, why does it have to be so geographically distributed? Why put data centers in cities? Why not just put the data centers near clean power sources?

In fact, using AI requires also inference power that needs to be closer to the consumers to reduce latency.

Re:The Claude Delusion by simoncion on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:16AM (#50508074)
> ...why does it have to be so geographically distributed?

Probably because of economics, politics, and logistics. Much easier and safer to have a bunch of relatively small projects running in a large variety of jurisdictions than one fuckoff-huge project that's the size of all of the smaller projects combined, don't you think? There's probably some folksy saying about that sort of thing...

> Why not just put the data centers near clean power sources?

a) Unless you live in Texas, folks in the US are connected to a nationwide electricity-distribution grid. Folks in nearly all other other countries are in similar situations. Proximity to generation is nice, but not mandatory.

b) If there was grid capacity available to run the new datacenters that are in various stages of project completion, why would they be running on-site natural-gas fired turbines? Those are way less efficient and way more expensive to run than grid-scale generation facilities. That'd be a huge waste of money if the datacenter operators could hook into the grid, yeah?

> ...that needs to be closer to the consumers to reduce latency.

Needs? No. RTT all the way across the globe is right around 250 milliseconds; I checked. For this part of these sorts of programs, servers in the same region as their clients are nice to have but not at all required.

Re:The Claude Delusion by verdverm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:54AM (#50498021)
Jeven's Paradox means chip effeciency will be moot. It's about footprint and macro measures
Re:The Claude Delusion by api on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:54PM (#50499143)
Depends on how big the efficiency gains are. There is not infinite demand. Jevon’s paradox occurs when there is latent demand that is released at a lower price point.

I also found that these projections are 15 years ahead and assume nearly all power is from gas when battery and solar costs are still falling geometrically and data center demand has reignited modular nuclear interest.

Re:The Claude Delusion by verdverm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:15PM (#50499323)
Some things that have thrown all CO2 / gas projections off are

1. Trump's War

2. Falling birth rates

3. Petro vs Electro state directions (Russia -> US -> China)

There are also unknowns around the thawing of the permafrost at northern latitudes.

Re:The Claude Delusion by api on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:06PM (#50499809)
Yeah my biggest concern is we have already tipped the climate and it’s currently ratcheting up to the next stable slot… one where we maybe lose Miami and experience huge agricultural region shifts that will destabilize governments and societies.

But hey. FAFO. We will live and adapt. Humans are like cockroaches, as a bio professor said to me once, and he explained that this is not an insult.

Re:The Claude Delusion by verdverm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:52AM (#50498004)
The 15 years is a projection based on data center build outs and gas turbine generators like those Collosus uses.

Hyperscalers want to build out enough that the trend will reverse. How much is t.b.d., America is likely to slow down the buildout