Re:Ask HN: Why was Aaron Swartz so special?
by temphn on Sunday January 13, 2013 @04:11AM
(#5050367)
> His case was a simple hacking case (as the crime is defined in federal statutes). There was nothing special about it politically or technologically or procedurally
The prosecution's case ultimately depended on whether or
not breaking a Terms of Service agreement can be deemed a
violation of the 1984 Computer Fraud and Abuse Act -- the
principal federal anti-hacking statute. While the law was
designed to ban hackers from spreading viruses and stealing
property, the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that
such activity includes violating Terms of Service
agreements.
The Seventh Circuit's decision was widely mocked by
internet experts, who noted that nearly anyone could become
criminally liable for reading blogs if a blog owner simply
set up an outrageous terms of service agreement.
In addition, a more recent decision by the Ninth Circuit
rejected the Seventh Circuit's reasoning in 2010, and the
Obama administration chose not to appeal the decision to
the Supreme Court.
I do not consider Aaron Swartz to be very special in the legal sense. His case was a simple hacking case (as the crime is defined in federal statutes). There was nothing special about it politically or technologically or procedurally. There was nothing special about the "victim" (JSTOR) or the victim choosing not to press charges. Indeed, even the fact that he killed himself is not unique because the incidence of suicide is higher with white collar crimes.
I am aware that my viewpoints on this differ strongly from most of HN, but if you read the comments by the other lawyers on HN, most of them generally agree with my sentiments in this regard.
Aaron was apparently very gifted technically (RSS spec, reddit co-founder, etc.), but as I know little about him in this regard, I cannot intelligently discuss this aspect of his person further.