News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by ShinyLeftPad on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:29AM (#50485880)
We pretty much never only judged the output. An oil painting is valued because it's an oil painting among other things. A chair crafted by a woodworker is valued over an IKEA chair.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by tomcatfish on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:42AM (#50486067)
Both of those things are visible in the output. An Ikea chair isn't denigrated because we're such snobs, but because it's made of inferior materials. If Ikea started selling solid hardwood bookshelves tomorrow at the same price as their other stuff, I'd be driving right over there!
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by komali2 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:48AM (#50486149)
No, because you can get indistinguishable hand painted oil clones of famous paintings from Vietnamese rep shops and they obviously sell for far less than the originals.

Barring AI generated art and prose assets is valid, if for example you don't want to have the AI generation marker on steam, or you object to the use of AI for various ethical reasons. Also there's apparently quite the market of motivated purchasers that want to signal their anti AI values by buying from projects that don't use AI.

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by bigfishrunning on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:53AM (#50486219)
> If Ikea started selling solid hardwood bookshelves tomorrow at the same price as their other stuff, I'd be driving right over there!

better go quick, they'll end up losing a lot of money selling more expensive furniture at a cheaper price...

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by rootusrootus on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:55AM (#50486256)
Ikea does sell some hardwood furniture, though I don't know if any of their bookshelves are. But it's definitely within the realm of possibility.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by ShinyLeftPad on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:30PM (#50487709)
> Both of those things are visible in the output

Yes, they are different, but even with woodworker's one worse we still value it more.

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by Toynbeeidea on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:37PM (#50486872)
Hmm, I don't know that time invested inherently equates to quality. I would place FAR more value on a comfortable functional mass-assembled chair than some wobbly piece of crap some guy spent two weeks cobbling together in his garage.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by ShinyLeftPad on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:31PM (#50487719)
It's not just time, it's also effort and other non obvious things.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by Toynbeeidea on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:45PM (#50487927)
Time and effort are not indicitive of quality.

I suppose we're talking about "craft" vs "art." Making chairs is a craft. There are objectively "right" ways to do it. You can still be artistic about it, so long as the craftsmanship is sound. That being said, I will take a well-crafted chair over one that is not every time over the "artistic" one.

With regards to writing, I can't just throw word salad together and call it a day. But my writing style is my own voice - I pretty much write the same way I speak. With AI... well, after you've read enough of it, you notice that it, too, has its own voice. Like, I can distinguish the writing style of Gemma4 real quick. It smells like ozone.

I don't necessarily mind, so long as its telling me something coherent and accurate. You could argue it lacks originality, and it certainly lacks agency: But it IS usually well-crafted. I'll take it. Won't stop me from reading, say, PKD novels.

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by ShinyLeftPad on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:47PM (#50487947)
Define quality.
Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by Toynbeeidea on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:47PM (#50487955)
Time and effort are not indicitive of quality.

I suppose we're talking about "craft" vs "art." Making chairs is a craft. There are objectively "right" ways to do it. You can still be artistic about it, so long as the craftsmanship is sound. That being said, I will take a well-crafted chair over one that is not every time over the "artistic" one.

With regards to writing, I can't just throw word salad together and call it a day. But my writing style is my own voice - I pretty much write the same way I speak. With AI... well, after you've read enough of it, you notice that it, too, has its own voice. Like, I can distinguish the writing style of Gemma4 real quick. It smells like ozone.

I don't necessarily mind, so long as its telling me something coherent and accurate. You could argue it lacks originality, and it certainly lacks agency: But it IS usually well-crafted. I'll take it. Won't stop me from reading, say, PKD novels. But miss me with the artistry of, say, Finnegan's Wake, or even Ulysses, I'm apparently way too dumb for those (yes, I've tried).

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by skybrian on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:01AM (#50497096)
The IKEA chair costs less, but to say it’s valued less is too simple. Valued by whom? Only a small minority will ever buy a chair that was handmade. Presumably they prefer it, but they’re rare.

IKEA’s many customers deliberately chose the IKEA chair. We don’t know what other chairs they might have preferred if they were the same price, because they’re not.

Re:AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers by ShinyLeftPad on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:38AM (#50497868)
> if they were the same price

Well that's the point a custom chair is valued more

I'd say most IKEA customers choose IKEA because it's cheap and they don't really consider or maybe even have an option to get a custom chair made, they don't know someone who could make one or they don't want to pay for it.