That's why we have IMDB Top 250 lists, and books called "Classics". Curating collections and having taste has always been important, and is even more important now.
AI hasn't really changed that. There is good investigative AI-assisted writing today and there is also fully AI-slop fly-by-night websites made in 15 minutes with Claude.
Maybe a revolution like the blind taste testing of fine wines needs to happen in literature.
For-profit taste-making websites like either got acquired and extinguished, or are in dire straits now, and in any event their influence over core audiences (especially young people with time for discovery) has waned to almost nothing. The non-profit blogosphere blogging about arts and literature largely grayed out and was never replaced; you can still set up a blog today, but you won't attract any real slice of your topic's fandom community like you once good. A putative scene hangs on at Substack, but if you look closely it's largely hustling and grifting.
All in all, curation just isn't there any more at a societal level.
My incredibly, almost insultingly oversimplified model for what I, a lifelong consumer of text, feels is happening here goes like:
90% of culture is "bad". 10% is "good". Previously, we'd iterate on the 10% and (I remind you: oversimplified) discard the 90%, but `derive :: culture -> culture` still follows Sturgeon's Law, so at the next iteration, 90% is "bad" and 10% is good. But now what's happening is we're iterating on the whole sample, and a polished turd is still feculent. So in the next iteration, 90% + 90% of 10% of the culture is "bad". And so on.