It always surprises me that people who are ok with a million immigrants a year, but maybe not ok with a whole lot more than that, are accused of being anti-immigrant.
I'm all for "letting people from everywhere come in and live their American Dream", but as a practical matter, I think there have to be limits. Well over a million a year, in my opinion, seems like a pretty generous limit, even for a fairly large country like the US.
One difference is that low-skill workers could make a decent wage until, say, 1950 or so. The current US economy doesn't work that way.
> Meaning every immigrant and his family ... pay taxes etc
Folks who don't make more than median wage don't pay significant taxes. In fact, they're a net-loss, tax-wise.
> what about all the other people that would not qualify for h-1b but are still very skilled and/or ambitious?
Good question.
Of course people are afraid of losing their job to foreigners, but if you look at the big scheme of things: every worker is also a consumer. Meaning every immigrant and his family will also buy more American products, go to the hairdresser, pay taxes etc. and thus indirectly create work for other people.
I really hope Obama is free market enough to make the moves in that direction.