Re:Electric Ship Batteries Promise Compact, Cooler Power
by bluGill on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:36AM
(#50470094)
sea water is too corrosive and too conductive. You could make a single overhead cable and use sea water as your return work. However it wouldn't be practical since ships multiple stories tall need to pass under the wire (and draw a lot of power), while also tiny fishing boards that couldn't even get a pole that high.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Electric Ship Batteries Promise Compact, Cooler Power
by jabl on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:01PM
(#50470473)
The same problem with height would also be an issue for the underwater thing. Quick googling suggests a very large container ship might have a draft of 16-17m when fully loaded. Probably you want the catenary at 20m depth then. How does a small get their pantograph (or whatever you'd call it) down to that depth, and then move forwards without the pantograph sticking 20m down creating a huge amount of drag. Not to mention how do you make the connection between the pantograph and the catenary in the (conductive) sea water?
Re:Electric Ship Batteries Promise Compact, Cooler Power
by bdamm on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50470616)
Make the cable AC and the "pantograph" a (water tight) transformer that glides around the cable. I can't see any other way - DC is not going to work.
Re:Electric Ship Batteries Promise Compact, Cooler Power
by mmooss on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:28PM
(#50470902)
Just looking at a couple problems:
> Probably you want the catenary at 20m depth then. How does a small get their pantograph (or whatever you'd call it) down to that depth,
Does the connection from the 'pantograph' to the boat need to be rigid? Use a cable? Maybe it's not for the smaller boats which can't handle a 20m (probably more like 35-40m for the angle and slack) cable, but also need less power and thus pollute less.
> and then move forwards without the pantograph sticking 20m down creating a huge amount of drag
Presumably, the catenary's route would be cleared of obstructions - maybe even on a frame elevated over the floor, maybe at relatively constant depth - or do I misunderstand?