News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by rayiner on Friday January 11, 2013 @09:53PM (#5046312)
That makes absolutely no sense. What would happen is that urban ISP's would win immediately, and then rural ISP's would be stuck basically cementing that lead in place by subsidizing the leaders' capital expenditures.
Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 11, 2013 @10:04PM (#5046333)
You're first assuming that there is such a thing as a rural or urban ISP. Have you seen the coverage map for AT&T or Comcast? They're all over the map.

But more than that, there is no reason to think that building a high speed network in a rural area would be impossible rather than merely expensive. So all they have to do is to do it first and they'll be the ones receiving the subsidy. And actually digging the hole in the ground is what costs a lot in rural areas, the terminating equipment doesn't cost anything more just because the wires are longer. So they install fiber to the home once and having paid that cost, the future upgrade costs become equalized with urban areas because all future upgrades come from upgrading the terminating equipment rather than having to put any new wires in the ground.

And if we ever want to have fiber in rural areas then that has to happen eventually anyway, so why put it off?

And, even if you're right, the result is still for urban ISPs to compete with each other to be the fastest and for rural ISPs to compete with each other to not be the slowest. The losers of that competition then have less profit for their shareholders -- or, if they lose very badly, their network is auctioned off to someone with more capital who can make the necessary upgrades. I am not seeing how we can lose here unless "we" are greedy telco shareholders who don't want to pay for upgrades.

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by rayiner on Friday January 11, 2013 @10:13PM (#5046363)
One fiber run to a high rise in Chicago hits as many customers as wiring up an entire town in rural Illinois. The idea that ISP's that serve less populated areas could somehow beat ISP's that serve mostly urban areas is completely ridiculous. What would happen is that the urban ISP's would win the race, and the ISP's with low density service areas would just go out of business perpetually paying the subsidy.

It's like trying to incentivize competition in baseball by requiring losing teams to subsidize winning ones. Basically everyone would just be paying to make the Yankee's roster even more iron clad than it is now.

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 11, 2013 @10:25PM (#5046389)
You're just making the argument that the amount of the cross-subsidy would have to be calibrated so that the losers are not bankrupted by it. We care about fairness in baseball because it's a game. Why do we care so much about it if this succeeds in getting the highrises in Chicago gigabit fiber, when up to this point we haven't been able to?

And let's go with it say you're right. Why can't we just create two or three classes of ISPs (like "cars" and "light trucks" for CAFE) based on their coverage density, so that rural and urban ISPs only compete with other rural and urban ISPs respectively?

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by rayiner on Friday January 11, 2013 @10:40PM (#5046409)
It's not a matter of fairness it's basic financial calculus. Internet speed is completely a function of capital expenditure. If you take the slower ISP's and siphon away money from them to give to faster ISP's, they'll never have any hope of catching up. At that point, the leading ISP's can just sit om their duff, because the other ISP's are basically paying to cement them in the lead.

This is true even if you separate rural and urban ISP's. Verizon has a great network in the DC area. If they win, then say a Houston ISP subsidizes them. At that point they have zero incentive to improve. Moreover, people in Houston are stuck with even worse service, because money that might be spent on capital expenditures in Houston are going to pad Verizon's profits in DC.

You're overly focused on the incentive part of the equation and ignoring the underlying market dynamics.

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 11, 2013 @11:02PM (#5046453)
>If you take the slower ISP's and siphon away money from them to give to faster ISP's, they'll never have any hope of catching up.

You're assuming that the effect would be that strong that fast -- that it would be large enough that they could never catch up. There is no reason the amount has to be that large.

And the Houston ISP doesn't have to catch Verizon in DC while Verizon is receiving the subsidy, it only has to catch the next-best ISP in the middle third who doesn't get anything and then it can get out of the bottom third who has to pay. Moreover, Verizon still has the incentive to improve even if they're the leader of everyone because the ISP currently at the top of the middle third is angling to get into the top third, and the ISP at the bottom of the top third is trying to get ahead of Verizon to keep themselves from being pushed out when that happens.

I mean what's your alternative? If you want ISPs to pay for upgrades either you reward them for doing better than average or penalize them for doing worse than average or both, and doing both has the added benefit of being revenue neutral. Is there some better alternative, or do you think the entire goal of upgrading connection speeds is unattainable?

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by rayiner on Friday January 11, 2013 @11:14PM (#5046476)
I don't think faster Internet is really a pressing national issue, and I think your idea is bizarre and smacks of the same kind of "clever" ideas that always end up disastrous in practice.

If high speed Internet is such a national priority, and the market won't provide it because of natural monopolies, then simply break up the utilities and prevent consolidation.

Re:Why Is Google Fiber the Country’s Only Super-Speed Internet? by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 11, 2013 @11:47PM (#5046531)
How do you break up a natural monopoly? They tried it with AT&T along geographical lines and we got what we have now. The expectation was that the Baby Bells would expand into each others' territory and compete with each other instead of buying each other, but if you prohibited them from buying each other, it still doesn't give them any reason to compete with each other instead of just continuing to milk existing infrastructure indefinitely without upgrading and silently agreeing not to expand into anyone's territory who doesn't expand into yours.