crudely, the "philosophy that data trumps everything" trumps "data".
which perhaps was roughly similar to what you were saying if we rephrase "the philosophy that data trumps everything" as "the ideas of the scientific method".
which perhaps was roughly similar to what you were saying if we rephrase "the philosophy that data trumps everything" as "the ideas of the scientific method".
For a fact to exist without massive supporting evidence via test data is outside the realm of science which doesn't make it much of a fact in my opinion.