Wasn't that the approach of some Cybernetic idealistits in the 50s?
That the world would be such a better place, if we just could ban intuition and let everything get run by machines?
Even if that would be hypothetically be possible, I would neither want to work nor life in a world like that. Predictability kills any excitement.
Isn't that a tad black and white?
I feel like data helps you reach the peak of local maxima. And perhaps that lines up with absolute maxima for mature industries. But I expect people still need to be involved to get us in range of the target.
The shift that we are seeing in lean startups reflects this - it is not a guru based process but a data driven one to start a company. Obviously, execution counts as well, but given two otherwise equal companies: One with a guru based approach (ala Steve Jobs) and one with a data driven process, I believe the inflection point has been reached where the data driven company wins consistently.