Re:To deter bioterrorism, U.S. imposes new rules on ordering...
by estearum on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:34AM
(#50455349)
Where are you getting this idea that a virus can't be engineered to be both highly contagious and lethal? Normally when I encounter this idea it's from people who are conflating a naturally evolved virus (in which this would be very hard/unlikely) with an engineered one. You've explicitly said you believe this to be impossible to engineer: why so?
Re:To deter bioterrorism, U.S. imposes new rules on ordering...
by ben_w on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:44AM
(#50455465)
> Where are you getting this idea that a virus can't be engineered to be both highly contagious and lethal?
From professional virologists discussing this specific risk.
The TL;DR (because I'm not a virologist myself, not just because this is a comment section) is that lethality works in opposition to all the things that make a pathogen more contagious, including long latency periods and choices of transmission vector and so on.
Even the worst case historical scenarios are things we now have a lot of tools for at the level of transmission vectors while we develop vaccines.
> impossible to engineer
Today. Impossible to engineer today. I would not wish to let anyone coming to the conversation late mistake this as an "impossible forever" kind of situation.
On the scale of "billions", right now it is impossible, not merely hard. As you say, it (likely) gets easier as the tech improves; myself, I am happy for things to get locked down ahead of time, but right now this wouldn't be possible for even a large and well-resourced racist government.
Tens of millions is possible, c.f. covid, albeit with essentially no control over who the victims will be, likewise c.f. covid.