Re:The Housing Market Is Nuts
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:03AM
(#50453570)
I would say there are several major reasons for ineffective government action:
- the wrong level of government has the power and the money. Housing is generally a local problem, but in many countries the cities are chronically underfunded -- higher levels of government have significantly more taxing power.
- misalignment between levels of government. Higher levels of government may be incentivized to increase housing stock. City governments are captured by NIMBY's.
- trying to do "easy" fixes. This is a hard problem; proper fixes are difficult and expensive.
- trying to preserve property values. People get really angry when their property values go down so governments try to have their cake and eat it to. They design programs that make it easier for people to buy houses. If those programs are successful, they increase house prices, making the problem worse.
Canada tried the "have cake eat it too" approach for 20 years and ended up with insane housing prices. The current government has finally adopted effective programs, addressing all 3 of your points. House prices are down this year in Canada; 1.9% overall, down 3.4% in the two most overheated markets.
What Canada has done:
- tying money for cities to zoning reforms
- vacant house taxes
- cut back on immigration
- directly building affordable housing
Notice that the above includes both the "right" and "left" proscriptions for reform. Both sides will claim that it's their proscriptions that's the effective one.
- the wrong level of government has the power and the money. Housing is generally a local problem, but in many countries the cities are chronically underfunded -- higher levels of government have significantly more taxing power.
- misalignment between levels of government. Higher levels of government may be incentivized to increase housing stock. City governments are captured by NIMBY's.
- trying to do "easy" fixes. This is a hard problem; proper fixes are difficult and expensive.
- trying to preserve property values. People get really angry when their property values go down so governments try to have their cake and eat it to. They design programs that make it easier for people to buy houses. If those programs are successful, they increase house prices, making the problem worse.
Canada tried the "have cake eat it too" approach for 20 years and ended up with insane housing prices. The current government has finally adopted effective programs, addressing all 3 of your points. House prices are down this year in Canada; 1.9% overall, down 3.4% in the two most overheated markets.
What Canada has done:
- tying money for cities to zoning reforms
- vacant house taxes
- cut back on immigration
- directly building affordable housing
Notice that the above includes both the "right" and "left" proscriptions for reform. Both sides will claim that it's their proscriptions that's the effective one.