So how do we make conditional commitments? Sometimes it annoys people when I won't answer yes or no to a commitment but instead say "I'll do my best." When pressed I can articulate the various uncertainties between now and the execution of the commitment that could derail it, but they are just that uncertain. Sometimes people say "Just say yes, and if something comes up let me know." I've done this in the past and had people accuse me of 'making excuses' which of course I feel is unfair :-).
There is certainly an element of 'value' here in that the consequence of not doing something has a cost and if the cost is small sometimes less effort is made in the follow through. If money is involved that is generally a more explicit definition of cost. But if someone says, "Hey my son Jimmy is on the special team at this weekend's High School football game, can you come by and cheer him on?" what is the cost of being unable to do that? Sometimes small (there are lots of people at the game) and sometimes large (this person really wanted to see you validate their support of their child's athletic activities) and sometimes in the middle.
Schneir positioned the transaction into the 'trust' category, you say you will do something and I trust that you will do it. The consequence of you not doing it is a loss of trust on my part. But the trust currency isn't previously established. Clearly my kids have a vested interest in keeping my trust level high because I can restrict access to the vehicles, but Bruce doesn't know me, and if he trusts me more or trusts me less do I care? Do I care $29 worth? Or more importantly do I care 'marginal value of Bruce's book minus $11' worth?
As you can read its something I wonder about but have few really solid lines of reasoning about. A lot of questions, a lot of speculation about the intrinsic forces in the 'trust market' and no clear experimental path.
Without debating the orthogonality of that assumption, (because it really won't change the overall point), let me begin by saying, most if not all humans I've encountered, have varying levels of principles and opportunism, but we are not made equal (CF fallacy of gray).
>I won't answer yes or no to a commitment but instead say "I'll do my best."
I am one of those, that have traditionally found that statement slightly annoying, especially in a business context. It just seems slippery. What does "doing your 'best' mean? Are you truly going to do your very best and drop everything to fulfill the request? I think not. Hence the precision one is aiming for, does not seem like an improvement on the original brevity of the yes/no.
Furthermore it could give one an opportunity to flake and blame the environment, versus sticking to one's word.
I completely understand this response, I actually really do mean I will do everything I possibly can to meet this obligation, but also recognize my commitment is not equivalent to other commitments by people who might use the same phrase.
I find myself stuck in this dilemma:
1) I can say "no" which cuts off the conversation and makes me appear unsupportive.
2) I can say "No, I don't think I will be able to." Which at least invites the requestor to inquire further.
3) I can say "I'll do my best" which accurately conveys my personal intent but sounds weak to the recipient.
4) I can say "Sure, I can probably do that" where I signal that my intent is yes but I can see issues which may interfere with my execution.
5) I can say "Sure" and 'bet on the come' as they say in Vegas which means that if things outside of my control happen in the best possible way I'll be able to fulfill the obligation, and if they don't I'll fail at filling the obligation and let you down.
I have observed that option 5 is the normal usage. It results in experiences like the one Bruce had where there are lots of commitments and not necessarily a lot of follow through. And at low "value" in terms of the commitment/cost the discussion of how much trust is impacted is interesting.
I've also observed that people in management that always say "yes" even if they only deliver a smaller percentage of the time on their commitments are more successful (in terms of raises, promotions etc) than people who actually only commit to things they actually think they can do[1]. So as a success strategy always saying yes, regardless of your understanding seems like a winning strategy. I personally can't do that though, I'm sure it has hindered my career :-).
[1] There is also a very real thing that you can often do more than you think you can, so sometimes over-comitting gets you to a higher level of efficiency. It still annoys me when someone signs up to do something that I know for a fact they won't be able to deliver, and they get full credit for the signup anyway.
I disagree. Although I agree that it is unlikely that it was their intent from the outset, there is a threshhold at which point someone has practically decided not to do something. Once they have procrastinated on doing something for X months and know that it is only #73 on their internal priority list, they have essentially decided not to do it. It could happen, but the odds are, what, maybe 10%? If you assume that a commitment to do something is giving a 100% guarantee and a commitment to not do something is a 0% guarantee, a 10% chance is, pragmatically, a "no".
Also, part of the implied deal was that you write the review promptly. From the original blog post where Schneier made the book offer:
> Liars and Outliers has been out since late February, and while it's selling great, I'd like it to sell better. So I have a special offer for my regular readers.
I don't think he was hoping they would send in their reviews a year or two later. Those who do would have a hard time arguing that they met the spirit of the deal.
The initial blog post was almost exactly 5 months ago and the offer was closed in two days, which means that a lot of readers probably got their books at least 4 months ago. (In my experience he does ship promptly, as I have gotten a book from him before.) If he was hoping that they would write their review in a reasonable amount of time, say 8 months, and only 9% wrote a review in the first half, I highly, highly doubt that even 41% will write a review in the second half. And the majority of those who will not probably subconsciously know it by now.
Edit: To be specific, I don't think he expected 90% turnout by this date, he's just disappointed that the turnout is so low by now. It's not even 1 in 10. 4 months is a decent amount of time to review a book you agreed to review.
I think the point is that a decision is an affirmative act. Nobody decides to forget to do something. It's like the difference between incompetence and malice.
But didn't they choose not to ensure they remembered?
That sentence sounds ridiculous. But if I care about something I'll ensure that I get reminded somehow so I can't forget. The experimental subjects that didn't provide a review either explicitly chose not to, or acted in a way that made it possible for them to forget.
The same sort of argument is made by people who protest a vote by not voting. Not voting doesn't convey any information as to the reason for not voting; it's lumped in with "didn't vote because of apathy" or "didn't vote because of illness". There's no way to infer intent from a non-action.
Phrased that way, the statement is absolutely incorrect. What is very likely is that a great majority won't uphold their end of the bargain. What is also very likely is that few if any of those made a decision not to uphold their end of the bargain.
Anybody who had that intention from the outset would have simply torrented the book. Anybody who didn't have that intention from the outset is unlikely to switch intentions. This is known as "consistency bias".
But what does happen is that people make commitments and then forget about them if the stakes are low. That is almost certainly what has happened in virtually every case of noncompliance in Schneier's experiment. I have a lot of respect for Schneier and his security and cryptography work. But his science fu is revealed in this article to be rather weak, as is his understanding of human psychology.