[Omitting a longish rant, that once we give up Lorence invaraiance we do no longer know anything.] AFAIK it is essentially the fine tuning argument. So not really generic but in the absence of a good argument a reasonable default value.
> What's this timescale have to do with it?
The timescale was essentially meant illustrative, so a short everyday timescale compared to gigayears. ( And it is conservative, in the sense that I do not need to remember the exact details of a GRB spectra to use this one ;)
> OK. Any idea how generic this expectation really is?
I can't comment on this case specifically, but the entire notion of the "Planck energy" is based on that idea: that once you've found the combination of fundamental constants with the right units, the numerical coefficient that multiplies it will wind up being within one or two orders of magnitude of 1. By some miracle, the vast majority of systems in physics seem to match such expectations.
> And the general expectation of some space time foam model is, that a,b should be roughly 1.
OK. Any idea how generic this expectation really is?
> compared to a rather short duration of the event ( ~ days).
What's this timescale have to do with it? They must be assuming they can identify photons emitted at the same time since they're measuring the arrival time difference in milliseconds.