News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by gaius on Thursday March 05, 2009 @07:44AM (#504198)
A 10 per cent payroll tax for each H-1B visa can be reinvested in whatever it takes to get American talent up to the same level.

Interesting comment. Critics of H1B note that it's not actually a skills problem, it's that you can pay an H1B with the same skills less and treat them worse because the threat of deportation hangs over them if they lose their job.

The solution is, if you have X skillset and have been paid at least Y dollars for Z years in your home country (to prove experience), have a visa that isn't bound to a particular employer, and also here is a defined process for getting a green card before that visa expires should you want one.

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by potatolicious on Thursday March 05, 2009 @09:06AM (#504251)
I've always thought that the H-1B system should be entirely scrapped in favor of an actual skill-based immigration policy. My parents were able to come to Canada years ago based on their education and skills in the tech sector. We had a defined path between landing and citizenship (only takes 3 years) which only made it more attractive. My father is now gainfully employed at over twice the Canadian income average, and my mother has started her own business that has contributed significantly back into the economy. It's a win win for everyone.

If the US is serious about recruiting top talent from the around the world they'd be wise to get on a similar bandwagon. Part of the H-1B problem is the abuse that's so prevalent, since an employee is essentially at a mercy of an employer until he/she gets the green card, which takes, in cases, up to a decade. I'm just about to graduate from college, and I know plenty of extremely smart people who simply aren't willing to throw 10 years of their life into a pit just for the privilege of being American.

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by goodgoblin on Thursday March 05, 2009 @09:48AM (#504276)
Another problem with H1-B is that any coworker you meet who is here on H1-B cannot actually get involved in your startup, if you decide to leave that company or work on it on the side. This actually stifles innovation. I worked with a couple of very bright H1-B coworkers who I become pretty good friends with, and even though they had the time and the inclination to work with me on a startup, they couldn't b/c doing so would endanger their visa status. We consulted a lawyer who told us that even coming over to make coffee on a regular basis could be construed as contributing.

If I had worked closely with people who could actually branch out and work elsewhere that would have definitely accelerated my project, but instead, though I value the friendships I've made, the acceleration to the economy via H1-B only occurs in terms of the work large companies can do.

Startups can't afford to sponsor H1-B and H1-B's cannot start their own companies.

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by mavelikara on Thursday March 05, 2009 @12:18PM (#504474)
> Startups can't afford to sponsor H1-B and H1-B's cannot start their own companies. If a person on H-1B is planning to get a greencard joining a startup, even if they can afford to sponsor the H-1B, looks like a bad idea. A GC takes about a decade to get; most startups never make it to that.
Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by potatolicious on Thursday March 05, 2009 @09:58AM (#504283)
Agreed. As a Canadian I sometimes bemoan the fact that startup culture is almost non-existent in this country, and that legally I have no realistic way of participating in an American startup, ever. But them's the cards I've been dealt I suppose.

There is always the TN visa, which is quota-less and hinges only on an existing offer from a company, so I suppose I could work for a startup. The TN, though, is not on a track to a green card.

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by alain94040 on Thursday March 05, 2009 @01:45PM (#504600)
I completely agree with your statement and find it extremely. sad. I too immigrated to join the "startup spirit" and wished everyone in the world should be able to do their own startups.

But then I actually did something about it, by starting my latest startup, which is dedicated to allowing people outside Silicon Valley have startups "just like here".

Fatality and entrepreneurship are opposite feelings I guess :-)

[plug to my startup not inserted]

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by miloshh on Thursday March 05, 2009 @09:59AM (#504284)
Are you sure start-ups cannot afford H1-B? It might be a few thousand in lawyer fees, but that might be well worth it, especially if a few key founders need H1-B. Since more than 50% start-ups had some immigrant founders, I'm assuming that a large part of them had H1-B rather than some other visa or green card.
Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by goodgoblin on Thursday March 05, 2009 @10:18AM (#504309)
I guess it depends on how early stage the start up is. Once you get some funding, sure, I guess you could spend it on lawyer fees, though there are likely many other places you'd be taking it away from.

Pre-funding though, or at the founder level, H1-B co-founders need a legal structure to transfer their visa to, or they can apply for a 2nd H1-B visa, but both of those options require a ton of redtape and hold an element of risk to their visa status.

Re:Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO by miloshh on Thursday March 05, 2009 @01:15PM (#504556)
Yes, that is true, in the early stage (before the start-up looks like a respectable company from the outside), it's more complicated. Ideally, you would use a different kind of visa, e.g. F-1 OPT if you have a degree from a US school, or TN if you're Canadian/Mexican. But I agree, the system is screwed up, and making it much harder for non-American founders than it should be. Let's hope Obama administration improves something...