News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Keyboard has a blacklist of phrases you can't swipe by hnlmorg on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:35AM (#50412027)
That’s a silly exaggeration. You’re literally just saying “there shouldn’t be a user toggle because developers have no self-control for stopping at one toggle”.

To which the obvious counterargument is just “well of course they can stop at just one toggle. That’s not an excuse to have zero toggles”.

Re:Apple Keyboard has a blacklist of phrases you can't swipe by Arnt on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:53AM (#50412847)
There's a story about the Microsoft Word team. I'm not sure it's true, but here goes:

The team had heard that most customers only use 5% of Word's copious feature set, and as part of some rewrite the team set about finding out what the 5% were.

And it was most of the feature set. Customer A used these 5%, B these others...

It's easy to say just one option without describing exactly what that should do. L10n raises some questions, for example. Or just two options, or three. Much harder if you want to be specific.

Re:Apple Keyboard has a blacklist of phrases you can't swipe by hnlmorg on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:07AM (#50412955)
We aren’t talking about completely disparate types of functionality. We are talking about enabling or disabling very narrow categories of words from literally one feature.

The store you mentioned wasn’t about exclusions from each and every dictionary. It was about tools that do entirely unique things.

Re:Apple Keyboard has a blacklist of phrases you can't swipe by Arnt on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:24AM (#50413106)
I think you're saying that it's possible that Apple can add the option you want and go on stonewalling other people's requests for other options. Right?
Re:Apple Keyboard has a blacklist of phrases you can't swipe by hnlmorg on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:40AM (#50413270)
I'm saying the opposition against having an option is "what if people want more options?" is silly and unproductive.

Do you make the same argument for everything?

"You shouldn't treat yourself to a takeaway because what if you want more takeaways?"

"You shouldn't buy a car because what if you want more cars?"

etc.