Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of C
by mikeash on Thursday January 10, 2013 @05:52PM
(#5040273)
I'd argue that there's a big distinction between C as described in the standard and C as actually used in real-world code, and the latter has much stricter semantics and is harder to work with. A C compiler that follows the standard but not the implied conventions won't do well.
For example, take NULL. Even on a machine with no concept of NULL, you could easily emulate it by allocating a small block of memory and having the pointer to that block be designated as "NULL". This would be perfectly compliant with the standard, but it will break all of the code out there that assumes that NULL is all zero bits (e.g. that calloc or memset(0) produce pointers whose values contain NULL). Which is a lot of code. I'm sure that many other examples can be found.
For example, take NULL. Even on a machine with no concept of NULL, you could easily emulate it by allocating a small block of memory and having the pointer to that block be designated as "NULL". This would be perfectly compliant with the standard, but it will break all of the code out there that assumes that NULL is all zero bits (e.g. that calloc or memset(0) produce pointers whose values contain NULL). Which is a lot of code. I'm sure that many other examples can be found.