News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by 127001brewer on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:05PM (#5038565)
I found the following blurb from the article interesting as it tries to make the information relevant the gun control debate:

Gun use emerged as a factor: Americans were seven times more likely to die in a homicide and 20 times more likely to die in a shooting than their peers. In all, two-thirds of the mortality disadvantage for American men was attributable to people under the age of 50 -- and slightly over half of that resulted from injuries...

However, why is this article interesting to the Hacker News crowd?

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by npsimons on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:08PM (#5038586)
Why is health interesting to anyone? Viewed in a more hackish light: here's a problem; how can we fix it?
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by 127001brewer on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:21PM (#5038677)
I find the entire "health care" topic interesting because I believe it to be "broken" (as a general term).

But what to fix?

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by roc on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:25PM (#5038710)
It's not a problem that can be 'hacked'.

Much like hunger in the third world: it's a political problem.

Practical solutions have long since been developed and proved in other places. The problems persist where they do, because there's no political will to actually implement the solutions in those places.

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by viraptor on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:44PM (#5038864)
> It's not a problem that can be 'hacked'.

While I agree it's a political problem in general, there's apparently a lot that can be hacked. Starting with lowering the cost of diagnostics and improving the information flow... There were a couple of interesting companies interviewed on Mendelspod (http://mendelspod.com/) - if you're interested in what can be hacked, give it a go.

There are also projects like http://nhshackday.com/

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by dtkuhn on Thursday January 10, 2013 @02:23PM (#5039119)
Agree. Patients need better information if we are ever going to be serious health care consumers. Doctors have very little incentive to help us shop for services. Co-payments, lack of reimbursement, etc are all tools used by insurers to reduce cost (combat moral hazard, etc), but very little has been done by patients historically to systematically lower costs.
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by maxerickson on Thursday January 10, 2013 @01:38PM (#5038812)
Most health care systems are grappling with costs and the demand for care outstripping the supply. It isn't a solved problem.
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by roc on Thursday January 10, 2013 @04:10PM (#5039757)
They're grappling with costs because their professional ethics require they treat people who can't pay, yet their business obligations require they don't treat those people until it's serious and likely expensive.

So because X number of people get X-Rays that will never be paid for, providers have to try to find some amount they can charge those who do pay, to cover the difference. And the trick with that, is that insurance companies know damn well what X-Rays should cost and have the bargaining power to squeeze out much of the padding in the cost of an X-Ray. [1]

Which means those costs are eating into profits in a big way and has healthcare providers struggling to make the math work out. Particularly for those that service poorer areas, where fewer well-ensured patients can offset the cost of uninsured patients.

And when you don't have a lot of slack in your budget, it's pretty difficult to add beds and professionals to increase your ability to supply healthcare.

[1] Which is another perverse incentive for the hospitals to use new machines/drugs/methods when old ones will do just fine. Firstly, they're incentivized because their profit is largely function of the percent of raw cost the insurance companies allow for profit. So an X-Ray++ brings in more profit than a bog-standard X-Ray for the same amount of professional time.

Secondly, because newer tools are by definition not yet commoditized, they can squeeze more 'buffer' into those prices, until the insurance companies can sort out what it 'should' be and more hospitals get in on tool X and begin essentially competing with one another, by accepting lower rates.

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by maxerickson on Thursday January 10, 2013 @04:40PM (#5039948)
I meant national health systems. Costs are going up everywhere (or at least, spending) and lots of places are having some issues providing enough treatment.
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by dtkuhn on Thursday January 10, 2013 @02:08PM (#5039014)
(1) Help Medicare track cost-effectiveness of tests/procedures involving really expensive technology (development of which will only get more & more expensive); (2) Teach Medicare patients how to become actual consumers of health care (how to shop for price/compare treatment options) -- i.e. help transfer some of the burden of reducing cost from payers to patients w/out causing mass hysteria
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by tdfx on Thursday January 10, 2013 @04:20PM (#5039815)
I don't think #2 will work without reforming the system to incentivize that kind of behavior. My grandmother goes to the podiatrist to have him cut her toenails (diabetes). There's barely any risk of her doing it herself, but he charges $200 every week for this treatment to Medicare. With her supplemental insurance, she pays nothing for these visits out of pocket. Why wouldn't she go?
Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by 127001brewer on Friday January 11, 2013 @01:57PM (#5044304)
Interestingly, the trimming of toe nails can be abused with "up-coding" as "minor surgery". When I worked with a group investigating Medicare/Medicaid fraud, this procedure was a commonly abused (with up-coding).

The point being is that fraud is a significant problem, but it's not easily solvable.

Re:U.S. health is lousy compared with peer nations, report says by dtkuhn on Friday January 11, 2013 @08:29AM (#5042556)
Chicken/egg. I'm not sure reform is practical until consumers have the help necessary to shop / compare. Otherwise, you basically have a bunch of old, angry voters.