News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by gpm on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:06PM (#50371527)
Playing games like this also makes it very easy to accidentally say things that aren't true, like in the headline of the article...

> Introducing Ripple-65B Preview, a Frontier Open-Weight Model

It's not "frontier", it's not "frontier" even in the category of open-weight models (though usually that phrasing would mean frontier over all, and also open weight)... it's only "frontier" in the small sub-category of US made open-weight models.

Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by GuB-42 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:00PM (#50372146)
It is technically frontier, if by "frontier" we mean the Pareto frontier.

Being at the Pareto frontier means that you can't get something better on one aspect without compromising on some other aspect. The trick is that it is easy to be at the Pareto frontier by having enough dimensions.

Here, we have 4: score, number of parameters, origin (US) and open-weight. You can get a better score or a lower number of parameters, but you have to compromise on at least one of the other aspects. That's a pretty weak frontier if you ask me.

Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by derefr on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:22PM (#50372326)
“Origin” isn’t part of the Pareto frontier because it’s not a quantitative dimension.

(You could say that “ability to be trusted by US government/military users” is quantifiable, but I would argue that by that metric, this model falls behind non-US-originated open-weight models that have more eyes on them!)

Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by Routine8502 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:37PM (#50372952)
Discrete dimensions can exist in Pareto considerations. Not that I'm too fond of this game, but given that "Origin" is definitely part of the calculus of model deployment, it makes sense to consider it in a Pareto calculation.
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by getcrunk on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:12PM (#50373253)
Ahh I run into this issue all the time with ai when applying any sort of dimensional reasoning abstractly it always implicits continuous
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by bastawhiz on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:30PM (#50373398)
It's just a different pareto frontier because you're filtering out items that don't fit your criteria. "Model was made by Anthropic" would be an equivalent dimension. You would never plot this, you're just reducing the subset of models you're comparing.

By that logic, any model is a frontier model. My GPT-2 clone is a frontier model when you compare it against models that were trained on my homelab.

Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by kennywinker on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:37PM (#50374832)
Which you're welcome to do and then people are welcome to disagree that is an important frontier to consider.
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by bastawhiz on Thursday November 05, 2026 @11:47AM (#50381346)
That's literally the point. It's a different frontier. If you say "frontier model" and don't specify which frontier you're either being deceptive or naive.
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by kennywinker on Thursday November 05, 2026 @02:07PM (#50383045)
All marketing relies on some degree of deception.
Re:Ripple-65B Preview: U.S. Open-Weight SOTA on Agentic Coding by jhgb on Friday November 06, 2026 @03:39AM (#50389712)
But Pareto optimality only considers ordinal information. Surely there's no reason why binary choices can't be dimensions in it.