News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by lnkdinsuxs on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:40PM (#50370496)
This is a blessing in disguise. The worst thing we can do is build an entire generation of humans who are uniquely dependent on a specific company (or even 5) to help them think, research and learn.

From there, it's incredibly easy to have forever customers for Gemini in a variation of Black Mirror Season 7, Episode 1: "Common People". In there, the wife is Amanda (Rashida Jones), and her husband is Mike (Chris O’Dowd). Amanda receives a treatment called "Rivermind" that restores her brain function but requires an ongoing subscription, initially $300/mo. Over time, increasingly expensive tiers, worsening restrictions, and involuntary spoken advertisements make their lives untenable. Eventually, Mike ends Amanda's life at her request, while she is unaware during one of those ads.

This doesn't mean we embrace the other extreme and instead raise an entire generation that doesn't know what will be considered basic tools like Excel and Word have been since the 2000's.

Infact, what would be fantastic if we, as a society, invested in (S)LLM tools that every student "owns" and can "tune" to their liking. Almost like an assistant that "grows" with them.

The idea is that these tools are theirs, in their control and for them to manage.

Unlike Fable, it doesn't arbitrarily stop a student interested in reversing software or hardware from learning the craft because they are not a licensed researcher.

Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by lifestyleguru on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:46PM (#50370559)
> requires an ongoing subscription, initially $300/mo. Over time, increasingly expensive tiers

That's going to be on top of a rent, or instead of rent?

Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by alex43578 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:46PM (#50370560)
What’s the point of that? We don’t make students write their own dictionary or build their own calculator as a prerequisite for using those tools. To your point about Excel and Word, most students from 10/20 years ago don’t know what Lotus is or how to execute commands in the terminal, but are still able to use computers effectively in their lives. There’s a multitude of search engines and LLM providers available - if schools don’t like what Google is doing, they are free to swap.
Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by lnkdinsuxs on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:54PM (#50370652)
> if schools don’t like what Google is doing, they are free to swap.

that wasn't my point at all. The point I was making is these tools make forever renters of intelligence. That's why I mentioned the BM episode.

It's not enough to have options in which service to rent forever.

Imagine if you had to rent your own own dictionary or calculator forever.

Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by alex43578 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:07PM (#50370794)
How useful is a set of encyclopedias from 1930? How useful is a set of encyclopedias from 1989 to answer a question about Russia today? How useful is a front end UI textbook from 2005, today?

You can choose to lock in a choice now: download a list of the top 10,000 websites or grab a local LLM. But realize that you will have to pay again as it ages out of relevance, or be left with a worthless out of date tool. The reality is you have to pay, forever (ooh, scary) for services. That’s what you’re renting: knowledge as a service. Whether it’s an LLM, continued program updates, or just an up-to-date encyclopedia.

Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by lnkdinsuxs on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:16PM (#50370894)
If you're making the argument that knowledge has a shelf life and so you're always paying to update that knowledge, I urge you to consider if those payments are onetime or recurring.

It also seems you are overindexing on current, volatile events. Unless you're in Quantum space, Newton's laws haven't changed in a while. Sorting algorithms still function the same as does the x86 instruction set or how the human body reacts to ibuprofen.

Did I get your point, or am I missing something?

Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by astr0n0m3r on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:52PM (#50370628)
Black Mirror is a show which blabbing about the ending to an episode is rather uncool.
Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by lnkdinsuxs on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:57PM (#50370683)
Apologies. I am fencing it with a spoiler. I wrongly assumed everyone's a fan and was caught up.
Re:Education Shouldn't Be Held for Ransom by astr0n0m3r on Thursday November 05, 2026 @05:17PM (#50385279)
Much appreciated, though I didn't even downvote you. Black Mirror is just a special case with standalone episodes that are more like films. Also, I find episodes so unnerving that I go months between episodes.