News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI stocks slide as Texas governor result raises data cent... by bodge5000 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:51AM (#50365507)
> The two are mutually exclusive insofar as the US' state of benevolence has no bearing on China's.

All due respect, I literally said that, twice. I suppose you could still call it whataboutism by technicality, but it doesn't quite have the same ring to it.

My point was that replacing a benevolent superpower with one that is not is quite a different situation than a "meet the new boss, same as the old boss" one, and I was just pointing out that this is the latter, not the former.

Re:AI stocks slide as Texas governor result raises data cent... by greggoB on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:43PM (#50373005)
You did, but disclaiming a whataboutism doesn't somehow negate elaborating on it.

> My point was that replacing a benevolent superpower with one that is not

I didn't get that from your comment; it rather came across as a laundry list for why the US is not benevolent.

Re:AI stocks slide as Texas governor result raises data cent... by bodge5000 on Thursday November 05, 2026 @03:17AM (#50376550)
> disclaiming a whataboutism doesn't somehow negate elaborating on it

I think it largely does. Look at the stated purpose of it in the wikipedia article you linked:

> It is an informal fallacy that the accused party uses to avoid accountability—whether attempting to distract by shifting the conversation's focus away from their behaviour or attempting to justify themselves by pointing to the similar behaviour

Pointing out that China is still responsible for its actions and the US doing it too doesn't justify them makes it whataboutism without a purpose. Like I say, whataboutism by technicality, rather than as a counter-argument.

> I didn't get that from your comment; it rather came across as a laundry list for why the US is not benevolent.

I think it can be quite easily inferred. We don't want China as a superpower because of X. The US is a superpower. The US also does X. Therefore...

Again, I said this at the end:

> it's just worth pointing out if that's a red line for a global power