News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Geoffrey Hinton: it might turn out we were better off wit... by graemep on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:04AM (#50364998)
It would be a lesser evil rather than good.

This sort of thing was going to happen, with or without AI (state sponsored hackers, the US or China taking down systems they control, or whatever).

The later it happens, the more we will be down the path that lets it happen, and the worse the consequences. We are getting gradually worse consequences: AWS outages taking down websites, GCP outages taking down banks, attacks on fridges disrupting good supplies...

Its better for us to change path when something happens that causes dozens of people die rather than wait until its millions.

Re:Geoffrey Hinton: it might turn out we were better off wit... by _heimdall on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:09PM (#50369326)
One can justify doing terrible things when the ends justify the means, in this case when learning a lesson sooner than later justifies all the side effects of a long power outage or similar.

The OP didn't say we should make it happen so I'm not intending to put those words in their mouth. Its a small leap from "it might be a good thing if the power is out for days" to someone hearing or thinking that themselves and acting on it.

If it turns out we have a power outage, people die, and we learn a lesson and adjust course then so be it. That would be what happens in that future but it isn't necessary and it isn't a good thing even if today we think it leads to the best outcome - we can't know that without knowing all the outcomes and would be generalizing into only the ones we can imagine.

Re:Geoffrey Hinton: it might turn out we were better off wit... by graemep on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:55PM (#50373105)
I agree about the invalidity of the end justifies the means arguments. I hope no one acts on it, but if (probably when ) it does happen and is only something like power out for days in a limited area it will be true that it could have been (a lot) worse. How much worse it could be is terrifying.