News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The lost malloc() by bregma on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:05AM (#50363884)
The answer is more likely that modern students just don't learn their history and think they've cleverly come up with something new (after all, it's new to them). If you've learned your history you would understand it has ever been thus. Aristotle and Hesiod complained about it, and Aristophanes even wrote a play satirizing it that could be performed today and it would still be relevant.
Re:The lost malloc() by 1718627440 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:36AM (#50366111)
Why do they go to university then? The entire point of an university is to get taught the fundamentals and be able to derive current (and thus future) knowledge yourself. If you simply want to learn the current state of a craft, that's what vocational schools are for.
Re:The lost malloc() by wahern on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:00PM (#50369204)
University provides you the opportunity to research and understand the history. You don't need university for that, but the time, people, and resources available to you make it much easier.

But it's voluntary. Actually course curricula basically just drop hints at the history as part of a short perfunctory narrative. Along with the deeper conceptual instruction (framed according to the then-current beliefs), that's better than vocational instruction, but definitely falls short of the idealized liberal education.

Re:The lost malloc() by 1718627440 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:01PM (#50372160)
Of course there is always a depth below, which to explore is entirely voluntary. But university courses don't train you directly on the layer you are going to solve the actual problems on your job, they test always at least on layer deeper and then maybe test for one specific algorithm/approach/problem as an example.

> you start learning geometry by reading Pythagoras, or calculus by reading Newton

You can do that, if you actually care about the history of mathematics, but normally it's enough if someone introduces you to a combined theory of e.g. Pythagoras and Newton.

So in a way you are saying, university is often not actually teaching temporal genesis, which I agree with, but my point is that it does teach causal genesis, with citations on the temporal aspect.