Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:37AM
(#50361833)
What you're describing is listening, not recording. If the bits only exist transiently on the wire and are given only as input to a binary classifier which transforms the stream into a simple true/false signal and are not written to more permanent storage, then it's hard to call that a recording.
Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by madrental on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:52AM
(#50362222)
Some would consider a Boolean signal to be a record of something.
Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:05AM
(#50362295)
Performative denseness is unbecoming.
Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by madrental on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:20PM
(#50370943)
Friend, if this is your response to a simple comment you may need to take some time away from internet forums to reflect on why you act this way.
Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by uncomputation on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:04AM
(#50367552)
A human listens. A digital system cannot listen because it must always write the analog signals into a digital representation: a recording. When you call `model(last 10 min of audio)` that is a recording. I suppose a system could "listen" if it somehow took as input the actual electrical voltages from the microphone receiver.
This might sound pedantic but it is very nefarious to me that Apple is marketing a device as "never recording" when it is actually always recording. And this is a claim going back to Siri with wake words. Again, they claim it doesn’t record and I don’t see the logic there.
Re:Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always-liste...
by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:00PM
(#50369206)
> A digital system cannot listen because it must always write the analog signals into a digital representation
A streaming hash function does not record its input. It records only the accumulated influence of the input on the output function. Recording a running statistical guess about whether you're talking and recording what you're saying are not the same thing.
> A human listens. A digital system cannot listen because it must always write
Bits on wire in audio frame at time t ~= position of your eardrum at time t. Neither are reasonably considered storage.
It does record audio. A microphone is constantly receiving sound waves and writing them in a digital format in a particular audio file encoding. That is a recording. I don’t see how this passes legal and doesn’t expose them to class action for false advertising.