News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by DangitBobby on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:27PM (#50356036)
You'd be willing to destroy your career to publish a warning no one will need?
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by jmount on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:35PM (#50356164)
Not me. But these are all "most important people in the world." So should fit their own narrative.
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by DangitBobby on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:39PM (#50356224)
This entire line of reasoning is just toxic. You represent a charicature of these people in your head and dole out self-righteous condemnation.
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by bilbo0s on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:37PM (#50356194)
Just, Devil's Advocate, but what would be the benefit of your career if all humans (or even just a few billions of humans) are going to die?
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by DangitBobby on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:44PM (#50356299)
I doubt you are asking in good faith, because I suspect a good faith interlocutor would have worked this out on their own, but I'll proceed anyway.

On the one hand, you've potentially got an indeterminate number of future comfortable years based on a subjective assessment of how long you think it takes catastrophe to materialize, with the downside that you can't warn anyone and so no one will stop the coming catastrophe.

On the other hand you've got the immediate assurance of your current career being gone and high likelihood that you'll struggle financially as a result, with the upside that you can provide a warning to the public that they will almost certainly ignore and catastrophe comes anyway.

Given the risk/reward assessment of those two options, what do you pick?

Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by bilbo0s on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:57PM (#50356485)
>Given the risk/reward assessment of those two options, what do you pick?

Listen, I understand that, owing very likely to our differing backgrounds, you and I think differently.

Where threats are concerned, I'm a simple soldier and as such I see things simply.

I would raise the alarm without a second thought. I honestly don't know how anyone could reasonably believe they would have any other option?

Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by zaphirplane on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:32PM (#50357777)
[delayed]
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by bilbo0s on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:16PM (#50358311)
I'm having a challenging time communicating what I'm saying.

Please understand, it's a job. I spot a threat to my unit, I report it up the chain of command.

It's not about whether or not there is a negative impact on me. It's not even about whether or not it serves a greater good; nor whether there is an ultimate benefit to my unit; nor whether I get brownie points when whatever you deem divine evaluates my soul in the hereafter.

It's my job to report. So I report.

I've never once considered the things you're talking about now when I was in any such situation. It was just a job.

Here's the thing, it kind of made me just automatically think a certain way. I know that if I see an existential threat, I'm reporting it. I believe anyone would. Not for benefit. Just because that's what you do. If you see a mass shooting in progress, you call the cops. I don't think there is a single person who thinks about negative impact or greater good. It's just automatic.

I was only saying that if the NDA would prevent them from reporting, then, to my mind, the threat is likely not existential. But, again, I do make room for the possibility that not everyone thinks like me. I just think it's very likely that people think exactly as I do when faced with that level of threat.

Maybe I'm wrong? That's fine.

Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by DangitBobby on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:31PM (#50358472)
Reporting up the chain of command in a structure that supports and encourages such reports is one thing. We are talking about an unsanctioned action that you take against the express or implied desires of those above you. And a legal system that will back them up, despite you having definitely done the right thing.
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by gradstudent on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:37PM (#50356195)
You mean, no other evilcorp will hire them afterwards?
Re:Google researchers demand freedom to tell the world what ... by DangitBobby on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:46PM (#50356321)
No anycorp, yes