News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology by throwaway5752 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:32AM (#50354140)
"seems a lot of folks here didn't grok the very terribly written README"

I tried to make it through the README and it was just unmotivated slop. Perhaps it reads better to agents. It is like the Van Halen rider story - if the authors didn't care to write a good README, what are the odds that they paid attention to the rest of the large codebase?

Re:Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology by gavinray on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:00PM (#50354571)
I had to go digging into the source to realize what it was, e.g.

https://github.com/NVIDIA/auto-ontology/blob/main/auto_ontol...

Re:Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology by Twirrim on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:02PM (#50354614)
I ended up throwing the README at an LLM and it gave me a much simpler and clearer explanation. Copying the bits of an explanation that helped me:

> The problem it’s trying to solve is that generating valid SQL doesn’t necessarily produce the right answer. An AI might find a column called revenue, but still choose the wrong dataset or misunderstand whether that figure includes things like refunds. Auto Ontology adds information about what the data means to help it make those decisions.

and then the one paragraph summary at the end:

> My reading: it’s a database chat application built around a reusable catalogue of business meaning. The question worth testing is whether that catalogue makes answers measurably more correct—and how much human work it takes to get the definitions right.

Re:Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology by throwaway5752 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:40PM (#50356231)
I could easily solve it myself, but the point is that I don't need to spend my valuable time on a project that the author's done care enough about to give a proper readme. And semantic web/graph indexers and queriers are not new, even if there are new tools at our disposal for classifying and querying ontological structures.

If they can't do that, it's a signal they didn't care enough about the details to rely on this project, and there is more cool software than ever I can spend my finite time on.

That may not be particular fair, and it may be a great project, but the bar is just much higher now.

Re:Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology by Twirrim on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:48PM (#50359332)
Sorry, yeah, I completely failed to say in my message what I was originally aiming to say. Lost sight of the message part way through writing, after I got pinged at work for something.

The fact that I had to throw an LLM at it to cut down the slop and turn it into something more succinct and comprehensible is nuts. For myself, I'd be embarrassed if I released something with that kind of README on it.