That said, the real question we should be asking ourselves isn't "Does the subscription box model work," but rather, "In which markets does it actually address a big problem?" Trends can be useful, but we need to read them with better common sense than we do.
http://www.reddit.com/r/coffee: 35,566 subscribers http://www.reddit.com/r/Wicked_edge: 26,612 subscribers
I have a few real preferences, so "box o crap" wouldn't work as well for me.
spolsky: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000056.html
Bordering off topic, but the smart people realize that you don't need to throw away your blades every time they get dull; that model is only successful because people don't realize you can restore a set of blades to service with a few minutes and some jeans.
So, you could say I've already disrupted it just in my own life, and the wider dissemination of that knowledge would just disrupt it further.
Amuse yourself, I guess...
If you're an intermittent shaver like me or someone with thick hair I bet they suck.
edit I thought you meant "leave the razor a week" but I think you mean leave your beard a week on second reading.
What he and you prove as a point is that to him Costco deal is perfect while your "thick hair" it too thick to save money with Costco. So the Dollar Shave Club will be perfect for you (to save money) and useless to him. Therefore, the DSC will never scale well enough because people like me or OP will never have a thick hair :)
1. Does this work for safety razor blades (e.g. the double bladed type)?
2. How do you do it?microscope before and after pictures here: http://teamdonline.com/technology/extend-life-razor-blades/
That said -- and I say this as respectfully as possible -- you're applying 20/20 hindsight in many of your examples. Fact: many women in this country, perhaps even a majority, have bras that don't fit correctly. Fact: women's boobs are highly variable, and do not actually fit into the standard cup size / chest size system that we've been using for the last 50 years. (An algorithm may be an over-engineered way to approach this problem, but the current model is far from perfect). Fact: men's razors are ridiculously expensive, and the razor & blades model is ripe for disruption. Theory (perhaps more viable than you might think): curated boxes of goods may, indeed, drive lead-generation and discovery, opening up new markets for apparel and home furnishings businesses.
I don't think it's remotely fair to look at the present-day struggles of companies like Dollar Shave Club or Trunk Club and declare, ipso facto, that their business models are fundamentally unsound. Perhaps their business operations are unsound. Perhaps their business strategies are unsound. Perhaps even wildly so. But the addressable markets seem reasonable in both cases.
Finally, I think you're cherry picking some examples and using them to draw a larger condemnation of the whole system. If we're going to declare that the system is rotten, then we need to begin with a macro-level evaluation of the system.