News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by blagie on Sunday November 01, 2026 @01:57PM (#50328521)
The problem is more about how we pick whom we give power to.
Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by mattm on Sunday November 01, 2026 @03:37PM (#50329566)
I think the problem is more about how do we get people in power that don't actually care about it.

You have to go through a lot of crap to get to a high leadership position and, in general, the only types of people that will think it's worth it are the ones who are attracted to the position because of the power benefits that it offers.

Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by blagie on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:58PM (#50358794)
Personally, I'm a big fan of selectorates. They avoid that problem. I'm also a fan of meritocracies, not in isolation, but as one branch. They bring a different set of problems.
Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by Gormo on Sunday November 01, 2026 @02:40PM (#50328950)
That problem doesn't really have a solution, though. Power inherently is a corrupting influence, and everyone is fallible. Focusing on building safeguards into how we choose whom to give power to, rather than limiting the exercise of power itself, will always produce dysfunctional systems.
Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by mlloyd on Sunday November 01, 2026 @03:27PM (#50329440)
Power isn't inherently corrupting. It just is.

People can be corruptable, fallible, greedy and unprepared to wield power over others - especially the people that seek out power.

The solution is to build better people from the ground up (culture and education) AND create institutional protections that function during both the absence and presence of substantial political power. I'd argue that, in the USA, we've done neither and appear surprised when it keeps turning out poorly for us.

Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by Gormo on Sunday November 01, 2026 @03:34PM (#50329532)
> The solution is to build better people from the ground up (culture and education)

No, it's not. Trying to reform human nature through some sort of all-encompassing utopian project always and inevitably (a) fails miserably, and (b) itself becomes a vehicle for corrupt power-seekers to pursue their ulterior motives.

> create institutional protections that function during both the absence and presence of substantial political power

Institutional protections formulated correctly are constraints on the exercise of power itself: strict limits on the reach of political power; checks and balances among multiple parallel institutions; mechanisms of public accountability, incentive structures that align selfish motivations with public purposes, etc. This is exactly the sort of stuff I'm talking about.

> I'd argue that, in the USA, we've done neither and appear surprised when it keeps turning out poorly for us.

In the USA, we've wisely eschewed (a) and avoided the disastrous failure modalities that entails, and instead pursued (b) quite extensively, to the point that things have in fact turned out reasonably well for us, especially in comparison to other countries in the world that have attempted the inverse (i.e. centralizing power with insufficient constraints in the hands of the "right" people, who are always the wrong people).

Re:Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power by blagie on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:38AM (#50361839)
This misses a point.

> Trying to reform human nature through some sort of all-encompassing utopian project always and inevitably

... succeeds, when done via:

> Institutional protections formulated correctly

Culture seems to converge to incentives.

A good book is Pinker's Better Angles. There's a huge gap between:

a) 1000-era human nature, where Khan took an army and raped and pillaged a major portion of the world, and people looked up to him for it.

b) 2000-era human nature, where we're talking about things like harassment litigation, antitrust, unsafe products, and election fraud

Virtually every country in the world at least keeps up the pretence of a democracy. A pretence might not be a fair election, but is still a world away from the various sackings of Rome.