News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Northflank Breached by Scorpiion on Friday October 30, 2026 @02:22PM (#50308098)
I'm curious what people think of BYOC (bring your own cloud) as an option offering to customers or buying it as a customer. Looking at Northflanks website they list it as an offering, I presume those customers are not affected by the breach.

What are your opinion on the concept? Growing trend that should be encouraged or a mistake for most startups? Would you choose one provider over the other because of it assuming price was about the same?

I get that this is often a super expensive "call us" option today, but in theory it doesn't have to be, so for the sake of discussion let's assume it can be delivered at a reasonable cost for the provider at reasonable price for the customer.

If people from Northflanks is reading this, I'm sorry for the incident and I hope you recover as soon as possible.

Re:Northflank Breached by captainkrtek on Friday October 30, 2026 @02:40PM (#50308344)
Depends on the nature of the breach, if its a flaw in the software itself, then perhaps exploitable both in the hosted offering and BYOC offering, though perhaps the BYOC aspect gives a bit of "security-through-obscurity" and less discoverable as a target.
Re:Northflank Breached by Scorpiion on Friday October 30, 2026 @03:01PM (#50308632)
Good point, there are of course different levels.

I was thinking of a fully private deployed within the customers cloud account connected to the software provider via Private Service Connect or PrivateLink and then either only available inside the customers private network or only via their own firewall. The point being that it's not publicly exposed.

Re:Northflank Breached by cflee on Saturday October 31, 2026 @09:24AM (#50315981)
What they refer to BYOC is bring your own cloud account for the cluster, while it still connects out to the same shared control plane (and that also connects into your cloud account) that is used for their PaaS offering. At least for BYOC with AWS the connections to the control plane all go over the internet and not via PrivateLink etc.

Since all your metadata and env vars live on the control plane, any issues there could affect the BYOC cluster.

There are some other options for a separate control plane, e.g. now they seem to have the term "forward-deployed control plane" which might be fairly close to what you're thinking of, but their BYOC by itself does not get what you want.

Re:Northflank Breached by mritchie712 on Friday October 30, 2026 @02:53PM (#50308508)
I was thinking the same thing on security-through-obscurity.

a hacker might know how to hack your service, but they'd have to find it first.

Re:Northflank Breached by aloknnikhil on Friday October 30, 2026 @04:29PM (#50309713)
We are increasingly seeing deployments trend in that direction. But trust goes both ways and putting systems in place to prevent abuse from either party is hard and needs to be thought through.