Re:NYPD's "Stop and Frisk" Policy Ruled Unconstitutional
by rayiner on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @08:51PM
(#5029673)
NYC's stop and frisk hasn't been heard in any higher court that I know of.
I don't really think they're distinct from Terry stops. Terry has two prongs: the seizure must be justified by a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity; a frisk must be justified by a reasonable suspicion that the suspect is armed and dangerous.
Now, they might not be valid Terry stops. If they frisk as a matter of course, that's not valid. It seems in the Bronx they're playing fast and loose with the "reasonable suspicion of criminal activity" prong. In a city, anyone walking down the sidewalk may be "about to commit a trespass" by walking into a private building. My argument would be that this by itself isn't a basis for a reasonable suspicion.
I don't really think they're distinct from Terry stops. Terry has two prongs: the seizure must be justified by a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity; a frisk must be justified by a reasonable suspicion that the suspect is armed and dangerous.
Now, they might not be valid Terry stops. If they frisk as a matter of course, that's not valid. It seems in the Bronx they're playing fast and loose with the "reasonable suspicion of criminal activity" prong. In a city, anyone walking down the sidewalk may be "about to commit a trespass" by walking into a private building. My argument would be that this by itself isn't a basis for a reasonable suspicion.