News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by genocidicbunny on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @10:31PM (#50283889)
> They can choose to not be soldiers but not everyone will be in a position economically to ignore the possible benefits. Miltary service is a strong path to escape poverty especially in the US.

Adding to this, if you're in the peacetime military and have a long contract, and congress or the executive orders the military to deploy somewhere, those soldiers won't even have much of a choice. As long as you're under contract, if the military says jump, most often all you can respond with is "how high?"

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by Computer0 on Thursday October 29, 2026 @12:30AM (#50284582)
So we should ignore the atrocities of people who sold their soul for cash because they sold their soul?
Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by croon on Thursday October 29, 2026 @06:06AM (#50286724)
While I'm some degree of a pacifist, it's tough to argue against the concept of a defense army, in the face of human nature. Defense in the larger sense also has to mean (preventative) intervention, for example world war 2 might have ended very differently unless the US joined.

I also recognize that the US has perverted this concept countless times since with blatant imperialistic motives, it does however still not break the concept of a just responsive military force.

TL;DR: They're not selling their souls if they (mistakenly) trust elected officials to work for the will of the people and only deploy for just causes.

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by couchand on Thursday October 29, 2026 @09:23AM (#50288645)
How can anyone look at hundreds of years of US imperialism with rose-colored glasses anymore? Who is really misguided into thinking the US army is defensive in nature? You have constructed a beautiful straw man.

Fortunately the Nuremberg principles rescue us here. Following orders is no excuse for abdicating a moral responsibility.

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by croon on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:55AM (#50290147)
> How can anyone look at hundreds of years of US imperialism with rose-colored glasses anymore?

I quite explicitly did the opposite of that.

> Who is really misguided into thinking the US army is defensive in nature?

Let me put it this way:

* Had Ukraine not had an army, it would not exist right now.

* Had Ukraine had a bigger army, it might not have been invaded at all.

* Had Ukraine had the biggest army in the world, it might or might not have abused it for nefarious reasons.

The argument I made is that the US (and any country) needs it for case 1 and 2 (can also be solved through defensive alliances, though Ukraine had assurances that were broken), but the US has gone the wrong way for case 3.

This however does not invalidate case 1 and 2.

> You have constructed a beautiful straw man.

I'm unsure how to respond to this other than state that it's ironic.

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by infamouscow on Thursday October 29, 2026 @11:59AM (#50291169)
The answer is you can't. It's irrational to have rational discussion with the irrational.

Derision is a legitimate philosophical debate strategy if the person refuses to engage in rational discussion and the points presented. Accurately describing GP as an irrational R-word is a social signal and warning to others not to behave so poorly themselves.

People need to abandon this enlightenment-era idea that if given enough time, you can sit down with someone, walk through all the facts, and persuade them to your side. There is no evidence of this working at large scale.

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday October 29, 2026 @12:09PM (#50291335)
Please consider posting comments more in line with the YC posting guidelines, with fewer shallow dismissals and insults.

You're not going to have a good conversation like this, and you aren't going to be "winning" anything for your troubles, either.

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by xphos on Thursday October 29, 2026 @01:34PM (#50292897)
Honestly I couldn't say this better. I would just go one step further participating in the Miltary does not equal your doing atrocities as a natural conclusion. We want people of sound morals to be in the Miltary because they will make I hope moral decisions when it comes to the conduct of war.

I highly recommend reading On War by carl von clausewitz. He gives a pragmetic opinion on War and being read for it. Along with being ready for general conflict both non-violent and violent

Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by genocidicbunny on Thursday October 29, 2026 @08:17PM (#50298191)
In that same light, all of us programmers sold our souls for cash to make the Facebooks and Flocks and OpenAI's of the world. Don't throw stones when you live in a glass house.
Re:Leak Exposes 41,000 Homeland Security Workers–Including U... by Computer0 on Thursday October 29, 2026 @08:53PM (#50298534)
Yeah I think those people are morally objectionable. I can defend every second of my history.