News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by rubberstamp on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @03:02PM (#50264102)
Any government side stepping law by interpreting law in any different manner than how it is written is breaking that law. In my opinion laws should not be interpreted at all and parliament should make any bug fixes rather than allowing courts or administration to interpret laws in any other way other than how its written down in the law.
Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by mrandish on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @06:14PM (#50266615)
> laws should not be interpreted at all

I get why that may reflexively seem right but such a blanket proscription would go off the rails and lead to unintended consequences you definitely don't want. It's simply not possible to write a law both specific enough yet broad enough to cover all cases. You or I can read a plainly worded law and think "There's no way this can be misconstrued, gamed or subverted" and, sadly, we'd be wrong.

> parliament should make any bug fixes rather than allowing courts or administration to interpret laws in any other way other than how its written down in the law.

It's certainly possible to theory-craft completely new and different governance, legal and justice systems from scratch which have different sets of constraints and trade-offs, but then it's a long conversation and unrelated to the existing U.S. system. If we limit ourselves to starting from what the existing U.S. system is and proposing modifications which are actually both constitutionally and logistically possible, then forcing all interpretation and clarification to be passed by congress would require monthly revisions, immediately breaking an already dysfunctional congressional system.

I think it's worth mentioning that in the U.S. system, judges interpreting application of laws passed by elected representatives is a feature not a bug. The U.S. system was designed to be adaptive and self-gating, so each of the three branches of the government have built-in checks and balances on the other two. Setting aside current politics, on a long time-horizon like the last ~50 years, I think the U.S. justice system, as imperfect as it is, is actually serving its designed purpose far better than the other two.

Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by rubberstamp on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @06:42PM (#50266907)
Usa is a common law based system where court judgements also serve as precedent rulings. It is more or less regarded as law even though its not passed by parliament/legislature.

There is another system, civil law based systems where law is passed by parliament and doesn't depend on any court precedents or court interpretation.

Might as well have just courts and call it as adaptive system instead of acknowledging that is isn't a good enough system. Europe has done better in this regard. Checks and balances hardly works in usa. Plenty of news on subverting various constitutional guarantees is example that it failed to work.

Proper democracy needs properly functioning non-lazy legislature. Making vague laws and calling it a day and leaving it for judges and lawyers to interpret based on whichever way the wind is blowing isn't democracy.

Legislature can also work 40 hours a week. Things can be more functional rather than dysfunctional. Active democracy and direct democracy where people can veto laws if necessary, in case representatives collude to pass draconian laws, would be the best kind of democracy. Only that can prevent erosion of rights.

Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by parineum on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:59PM (#50268459)
All laws are interpreted.
Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by rubberstamp on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @05:38AM (#50271053)
You wrote "All laws are interpreted". If I put an asterisk on "interpreted" that can change the meaning you actually intended. Laws should not be interpreted. People need to learn how to properly use words with its actual meaning and write laws that are non-ambigous. Its not hard or impossible to write proper law in simple and easy to understand way. Feel free to interpret any law with its original meaning of the word and sentence structure. If it leaves room for interpretation, it is a vague law and not a good law.
Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by parineum on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @10:49AM (#50274607)
> that can change the meaning you actually intended

Laws aren't made by one person. When everyone votes on them, they agree on the language because of how they interpret the words on the paper. The meaning is what the words on the paper say, which is interpreted by different people to mean different things before they even become law.

Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by rubberstamp on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @11:20AM (#50275174)
May be start attaching dictionary too as an appendix to law so that words are not interpreted the wrong way. Not having to explain meaning used to be common sense before double speak. But I guess now we need to idiot proof laws.
Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by IAmBroom on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:14AM (#50289446)
> If it leaves room for interpretation, it is a vague law and not a good law.

Human languages do not have exact, logical meanings.

It is very difficult to compose an English sentence that is not subject to possible misinterpretation.

Re:The US Government Is Hiding Secret Court Ruling About How... by rubberstamp on Saturday October 31, 2026 @08:30AM (#50315554)
I beg to differ. It is very easy if you know language decently. The limiting factor is not language but the understanding of what the law maker is trying to achieve. An analogue would be a good programmer and a bad programmer. Give them both same task description. Good competent programmer will most likely program exactly what the program needs to do and never breaks even for edge cases. Bad programmer on the other hand will most likely write a program that doesn't work accurately. The good programmer understood the objective. Every law can be written in easy to understand language and if the law is well written then it won't be vague.