News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by bryanlarsen on Monday October 26, 2026 @01:25PM (#50247487)
Agreed, e-fuels seem to be far and ahead the front-runner.

We can get to 95% using just short term storage. I suspect that most jurisdictions will just say "95% is good enough" rather than paying for ridiculously expensive long term storage.

We've got the nat gas capability already; keeping it around for the 5% is quite inexpensive, making the massive investment in long term storage for marginal benefit hard to justify.

OTOH, while the premium for e-fuels seems excessive, if you're only running that nat gas plant 2 days a year that premium is not so scary.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @01:53PM (#50247993)
> Agreed, e-fuels seem to be far and ahead the front-runner.

For covering Dunkelflauten? Yes.

For seasonal storage with a prolonged discharge (so, low power/storage capacity ratio)? I think thermal storage wins there.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by bryanlarsen on Monday October 26, 2026 @02:04PM (#50248183)
Sure, thermal is great where it's possible. But there aren't that many places where district heating is viable.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @02:07PM (#50248230)
I'm not talking about district heating. I'm talking about high temperature storage for conversion back to electricity. Round trip efficiency could be around 40%, better than green hydrogen burned in combined cycle plants.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by bryanlarsen on Monday October 26, 2026 @02:42PM (#50248861)
Standard Thermal's website's front page only covers heat delivery; did you mean to link to somewhere else?

Those are 2 very different use cases.

Thermal is low rate extraction. It's 1 cycle per year, but the extraction is performed over months so is low rate.

Electricity long term storage is high rate extraction. It's only used a few times a year, but when it is used it needs to cover roughly 100% of the entire grid's needs. I doubt thermal storage is suitable for high rate extraction, but I'd love to be wrong.

Edit: rereading your parent comment you seem to think thermal is suitable for a different use case? Could you elaborate further? When is "prolonged discharge" useful?

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @04:47PM (#50250692)
That's what they're focusing on to start with, but the temperature is high enough to drive heat engines to make power. There's more on the concept at the seed company's (Orca Sciences) web site and at Austin Vernon's blog.

https://www.orcasciences.com/articles/standard-thermal

https://austinvernon.substack.com/p/building-ultra-cheap-ene...

They talk about temperature up to ~600 C, which I believe is limited by the desire to use cheap steal (much hotter and creep becomes a problem). This is also perhaps not coincidentally about the temperature of steam from a coal fired boiler, so one of the eventual goals is to repower retired coal fired power plants with this storage providing the heat instead of coal combustion.

You're right this is not good for something needed "a few times a year" for relatively short periods, for example to cover Dunkelflauten. Combustion of an e-fuel is better for that. But it's well suited to seasonal storage of solar energy, as that would be extracted over months, more or less continuously. The resistive heaters should also be much cheaper per W than electrolyzers.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by bryanlarsen on Monday October 26, 2026 @05:06PM (#50250967)
> But it's well suited to seasonal storage of solar energy, as that would be extracted over months, more or less continuously.

But what is that useful for? During almost all of those months it would be a lot cheaper to use renewables & short term storage. And it's not fast enough for the few days it's not beaten by something cheaper.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @05:23PM (#50251193)
It's useful for storing cheap solar energy for use in winter. Sizing the solar collectors for winter would require them to be much larger. Basically, this lets 2.5 W of solar in summer deliver 1 W of solar in winter. For a high latitude where the change in insolation is higher than that, this is superior. In Hamburg, for example, insolation varies by more than a factor of 10 from July to December.

Put another way: if you oversize the solar to be adequate in winter, you have enormous amounts of surplus solar in summer. So why not store it?

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by bryanlarsen on Monday October 26, 2026 @05:43PM (#50251445)
> So why not store it?

Because 0.10 $/kWh(th) / 0.4 kWh(e)/kWh(th) is expensive.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @07:15PM (#50252529)
That's the capex for storage capacity. It's amortized over the number of charge/discharge cycles. Divide by 20 or more. It's amazingly cheap, actually.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by skybrian on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:06PM (#50253867)
I thought that post was interesting when I read it over a year ago, but the startup seems to have gone dark since then.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:56PM (#50254216)
They appear to be focusing on Europe, and have raised $11M (or maybe 11M euros, I'm not sure which). There is some favorable buzz in Germany, which makes sense because natural gas has become quite expensive there.

https://www.cleanthinking.de/thermischer-erdspeicher-erdhueg...

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by cyberax on Monday October 26, 2026 @08:50PM (#50253369)
I just don't see it with thermal. You have to pay the Carnot tax, and you also need humongous amounts of material.

E.g. 100 GWh (4 days of 1GW thermal power) with a 100C temperature swing (you can't go down all the way to room temperature) will need around 3.6*10^4 tons of sand. That's a lot.

Honestly, power-to-gas sounds like the only reasonable way for now. In theory, with SOFC (Solid Oxide Fuel Cells) for power generation, it can beat the steam cycle.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @09:19PM (#50253563)
The temperature swing can be much greater than 100 C. Heat can be extracted as a wave passing through the store, then heat added back by reversing the flow. It would operate like a counterflow heat exchanger.

View another way: if we hook several piles in series, then lukewarm air from a first mostly discharged pile can be directed into later piles for more heating. In the continuous limit this is the concept I described above.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by cyberax on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:13PM (#50253923)
> The temperature swing can be much greater than 100 C.

No, because your steam will be at a lower temperature as you draw down the heat, bringing down efficiency.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by adgjlsfhk1 on Monday October 26, 2026 @11:39PM (#50254473)
Realistic designs for this can achieve 450C delta t. Your energy store can store at ~1000C (slightly below rock melting point), and run steam turbines with a hot side of 600C and a cool side of 150C.

Over the season, your sand drops from ~1000 to ~600 (which is fine since your power needs drop in the spring)

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by cyberax on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @02:54AM (#50255455)
Sorry, but 1000C is wildly unrealistic. There are no bulk materials that can be used to construct heat exchangers for this kind of environment. 600C is already a stretch.

At 1000C steel will react with _water_.

To be clear, I'm not talking about cooling a small crucible but a structure that is at least 20 meters in size.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @06:39AM (#50257069)
At 600 C one can use stainless steel, but things rapidly become expensive and problematic beyond that. 1000 C would require Inconel or something.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @11:04PM (#50254269)
That is wrong, and I already explained why.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by Panzer04 on Monday October 26, 2026 @09:06PM (#50253463)
36000 tons... doesn't actually sound like that much? That's a ~30x30m cube of dirt.

But I have no reference for the cost of setting up such a storage and how it compares to battery or hydro.

Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by adgjlsfhk1 on Monday October 26, 2026 @11:50PM (#50254519)
The ~grid scale design of this for reference is somewhere around 200mx200mx50m for above ground, or ~100m cube (or bigger) for quarry infill. Such a design is going to get crushed by battery/hydro over the hours/days, but wins on cost for seasonal usage.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @09:11PM (#50253504)
The cost of putting dirt in a pile is $1-2/ton.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:00PM (#50253829)
so $36-72k for days of 1GW of power? Sounds pretty cheap to me ...
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:12PM (#50253922)
They also state the cost per kWh(th) of storage capacity is about $0.10, or $100,000/GWh(th). This is thermal energy, which is converted to work at maybe 40% efficiency, mind you. There are costs over and above the dirt (for example, pipes laid through the dirt to carry heat in/out).
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by cyberax on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:18PM (#50253977)
The biggest expense will be the pipework inside that pile. That you won't be able to service easily. And you'll also need a LOT of insulation around it to prevent heat from leaking out too quickly.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by adrianN on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @12:18AM (#50254662)
Thermal storage benefits from the square/cube scaling, so the amount of insulation goes down as you scale up the storage.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:34AM (#50259064)
Even better than that: the thermal time constant is proportional to the square of the radius. There's the square/cube effect that causes a factor of r ratio in the volume to surface area, but there's also a factor of r from the temperature gradient (which, from the center of the pile to the surface, is inversely proportional to r).
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Monday October 26, 2026 @11:05PM (#50254278)
The insulation is just more dirt.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by cyberax on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @12:36AM (#50254746)
Homework: compute the heat flux from a 40 meter radius sphere, given the surface temperature 600C and the ambient temperature 0C. Now compute the amount of insulation needed to keep its temperature above 500C for 3 months, given that dry sand has an R value of 0.25 W/mK.
Re:'It's offensively cheap': Solar power is quietly becoming... by pfdietz on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @06:43AM (#50257105)
Note that the thermal time constant of a given geometry scales as the square of the radius. This is why subsurface geothermal heat is there even though it was "charged" gradually over millions of years. So it's not hard to achieve very long time constants just by making the pile a bit larger. They've done these computations. The result is the minimum practical size is a pile that provides ~100 kW(th) constant output.

So the idea is not practical for storage for an individual home, but could work on the scale of a village or small industrial enterprise. It would allow a solar microgrid to be completely disconnected from the larger grid, even at high latitude (assuming one could get a sufficiently good heat engine to work at that scale; it's a bit small for steam turbines.)

If you look at very large piles of dirt, like large earthen dams, if arranged in a suitable geometry they would have thermal time constants (assuming no fluid flow through them) in the thousands of years.

A computation for you: compute the cost of a given R value per m^2 for various materials. Dirt is very cheap, so even if it's not the best insulator it comes out on top. You need the thing being insulated to be large enough that you can fit the thick dirt layer around it, of course.