But that's not what tptacek is referring to. He's referring to the "I want something for nothing" sense of entitlement. You have no moral right (entitlement) to read their content without viewing the ads the put up. That's why ad-blocking has never sat right with me: it's implicitly accepting that the model of ad supported, free content can not work on the internet.
If you make the content of your site freely available with the knowledge that users can access your site in a way that circumvents your business model you've signed up for a business model that isn't dependable.
This is no different than a street musician wanting money from people that stop to listen to the music they play. Maybe the listener, having heard the music, determines it's not of any monetary value. Are they obligated to pay anyway? No, and the street musician knows this. They understand that only a certain percentage of people that stop to listen will actually pay anything. It's true, too, that maybe someone will listen to the music and be unable to pay. Should they block their ears as they walk past because they cannot give what the musician would like to receive for his service? In the case of a screen reader, maybe the user doesn't even know the ads exist.
If the street musician decides his business model isn't supporting him as much as he'd like, maybe he'll stop playing music. And will the public that decided to not pay him anything really care that he doesn't play it anymore? No. They decided it wasn't valuable enough to pay for.
If you feel your content is worth something or you need money to continue providing it, you should charge people for it outright, or make an explicit request for donations. If people find value in your content and are able to, they will pay for it.
It should not be expected that when you put content freely available somewhere, whether it be publishing a blog or playing music in the street that everyone who reads or hears it finds it of equal value or is willing and able to pay for it. You, as that site owner or musician do yourself a disservice if you expect otherwise.
Secretary: right away. [takes out scissors and cuts out only the relevant parts]
Boss: great!
s/Boss/user/, s/Secretary/Software/
Once a byte stream of information comes under the control of another user, what they do in their own time and privacy is entirely up to them. It may even be illegal, but it is outside of your control.
We can do this whole "immoral vs moral" and "gentleman's agreement thing." But depending on how gentlemanly you want to be, you can make the tacit agreements infinitely complicated, inefficient, and uneconomical. Example: reading on a small-screen device. Another example: ads on train.
If I watch a TV show with commercials, do I have a moral right to go to the bathroom during the commercial breaks, even if I won't be able to hear the commercials from inside the bathroom?
My personal stance, evolved over the years, basically allows me to do anything short of blocking ads. The cost, I have decided, for accessing ad-supported content is the open-mindedness that while I will subconsciously ignore almost every ad on the web, that I am mentally open to the possibility of being intrigued by an ad enough to click on it.
It seldom happens, but not having blocked the ads, the fact that it happens ever gives me a clean conscience.
You have the right to browse the internet in any manner that you see fit. But you are in no way morally entitled to any particular content just because it exists. I see ad-supported sites as gentlemen's agreements: we give you content if you view our ads.
I'm sure back in the Dark Ages, DARPA and the universities did not invent the interwebs with advertising and in mind. Trying to come up with a "business model" for "generating revenue" while "delivering content" has been bolted on to a system this wasn't designed for. (Aside: and the internet wasn't invented with security in mind, which is why we perpetually bolt together solutions to thwart spammers and botnets.)
Sites like Wikepedia are donation based, and run as non-profits.
(For the record, I actually worry if my coffee purchase really does offset my resource usage when I stay for 3-4 hours in my local coffee shop on weekends.)
Theoretically speaking. See:
http://www.slate.com/id/2132576/?dupe=with_honor +
"I opened a charming neighborhood coffee shop. Then it destroyed my life."
+ No clue what that query parameter is doing there, but I got to it with Google.
"Oh, really?" I type into my heavily modded Firefox browser because some computer graphics give me brain seizures. (Too bad I cannot log into HN from my Lynx browser.)
Last time I checked, the industry term for a browser is "user agent," and page rendering is under the control of the user agent. I can use whatever user agent I want, and so can you. I can fiddle with my user agent as I see fit, and so can you. That's what your browser's Options dialog is for.
Sorry I'm getting really testy here, but I get tired of pointing out to the world that it's the user who is in control, not marketers, not page designers, not Yahoo! CSS Reset...